Prevalence of Various Cancer-Related Risk Factors among the Forcibly Displaced Myanmar National Community, the Rohingya, in Bangladesh: A Preliminary Assessment ()
1. Introduction
In 2017 due to an escalation of violence against the Rohingya Communities of the Rakhine State, close to 700,000 people fled across the border to Bangladesh without supplies, food and non-food items, or medicine [1]. There are five domains of survival for refugees and migrants: access to healthcare, food and nutrition, shelter, water and sanitation, and communication [2]. Communicable and vaccine preventable diseases are an immediate concern in this largely unvaccinated population [3]. Basic medical care has been provided through the health sector, which is coordinated under the Civil Surgeon’s Office of Cox’s Bazar, the Directorate General Health Services, and the World Health Organization [4]. Organization of health outreach and communication of services to communities goes through the refugee camp social structure which uses a Majhi, a leader who is chosen by the community to communicate with the host community [5]. Under the Majhi, there are several deputy Majhis who speak for and represent a group of families.
The forcibly displaced Myanmar nationals (FDMN) or Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh face many obstacles to preventive health care. Identification of cancer risk factors and the detection and treatment of life-limiting diseases are neglected areas of health intervention among the FDMN Rohingya refugees. Rohingya people have large families and a high level of illiteracy. Seventy-six percent of Rohingya adults had no education and within the refugee camps; fifty-two percent of children did not attend school. Almost 80% of household reported no current income [6]. To better understand the challenges and health concerns for this stressed and deprived community and develop effective interventions, it is necessary to assess incidence and prevalence of risk factors for life-limiting illnesses.
Risk factors for life-limiting illness and cancer in particular can be related to genetic or environmental factors. Additional risk factors for poor outcomes include lack of access to health services including the availability of well established cancer screening programs, inability to make one’s own medical decisions based on the family or community hierarchy and poor health literacy. Specific individual and community risks for the development of cancers and life-limiting illnesses include poor personal and community hygiene causing the spread of infectious diseases and the risk of malnutrition, which reduces individual immunity to illnesses. Additional personal risks include exposure to carcinogenic agents such as tobacco and alcohol; cancer associated infectious diseases such as high-risk human papillomavirus infections (HPV), hepatitis C, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and well as malaria, dengue, and many childhood infections such as measles. There are no studies among the Rohingya population about the prevalence of cancer promoting risk factors.
This study measures prevalence of cancer-related risk factors of families of FDMN Rohingyas and identifies currently available interventions. Understanding the levels of cancer-related and health-related knowledge will enable a healthcare program to be tailored more appropriately to the needs of the population. Educational outreach among the population and the caregivers of the ill can be given to improve health outcomes.
2. Methods
2.1. Study Site and Population
This study was conducted at Kutupalong camp 2 in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar. All the patients were seen at the camp’s two health facilities. Men and women who were able to consent and were between the ages of 18 years and 65 years were included in the study. Exclusion criteria were as follows: those who were unable to consent and people who had incapacitating health issues or mental disability where it was felt they could not give informed consent. Participants gave informed consent. Face-to-face interviews were conducted by the authors for 30 minutes in Bangla with the help of a Rohingya language interpreter. Rohingya, the language spoken by the Rohingya people of the Rakine State, is an eastern Indo-Aryan language coming from the Bengali-Assamese branch [7]. Table 1 shows the questions asked of all participants.
2.2. Study Approach
A descriptive qualitative approach was used to understand the socio demographic aspects of the Rohingya population and of the local people residing in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar. On 2nd & 3rd of July 2019 we visited the Rohingya camp 2 Kutupalong, where we interviewed 85 participants coming to the two different health facilities. Our team also included an educational session on Self Breast Examination (SBE). This was a qualitative study and there was no sample size analysis.
2.3. Study Design and Period
This study was conducted by a cross-sectional design and was conducted from April 2019 to August 2019. A structured questionnaire was used to collect information from the study population.
2.4. Definitions for Scoring Pain and Cancer Risk Factors
For evaluation of pain, the numeric pain rating scale (NRS) was used where 0 means no pain, 1 - 3 mild pain, 4 - 6 moderate pain, 7 - 10 severe pain [8]. Cancer risk factors for oral, lung, cervical, and breast cancers were assessed using
Table 1. Questionnaire used on 85 Rohingya Participants.
validated questionnaires [9] [10] [11].
2.5. Sampling Technique
Purposive sampling was done with the study population considering the feasibility of the study. Purposive sampling is a technique also known as judgmental, selective, or subjective sampling. It is a form of non-probability sampling in which researchers rely on their own judgment when choosing members of the population to participate in their study [12].
2.6. Study Variables
Cancer risk factors were considered as dependent variables and socio-demographic and education information were independent variables.
2.7. Ethical Approval
Approval was collected from the Refugee Relief and Repartition Commissioner Office. During data collection, informed written consent was collected from study participants. Prior permission was obtained from the Refugee Relief and Repatriation Commissioner. In addition, permission was received from the Director of Camp 2 and the Cox’s Bazar health complex.
2.8. Data Processing
After developing questionnaire to check the reliability, the study tools were pre tested among the Rohingya refugees. Any issues of language, comprehension, and content found on the questionnaire were reviewed and corrected accordingly.
2.9. Statistical Analysis
Translation in Bangla and back translation was done to ensure the accuracy of data. Data were analyzed using IBM SPSS software version 23.
3. Results
Table 2 represents information on socio-demographic characteristics of the participants. A total of eight-five participants were interviewed at the health facilities. The average age of women was 25 years (range 18 to 65 years). The average age of men was 30 (range 18 to 50 years). Seventy-five (88.2%) were female and ten (11.8%) were male. Seventy (82.4%) participants had not received any formal education, ten (11.8%) participants had completed their primary level education and only five (5.9%) participants had completed secondary school. All the women were housewives and all the men were unemployed within the refugee camp. Fifty (58.8%) of the participants lived as nuclear families and 35 (41.2%) had extended families. Table 3 summarizes the health literacy of the participants. Fifteen (17.6%) people were familiar with lung cancer, twenty-five (29.4%) people knew about breast cancer, ten (11.8%) people had heard of cervical cancer,
Table 2. Socio-demographic Profile of 85 Rohingya Participants in the Kutupalong Refugee camp in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar
Table 3. Health literacy for cancer of 85 Rohingya Participants in the Kutupalong Refugee camp in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar.
and five (5.9%) were familiar with oral cancer.
Table 4 shows prevalence of cancer-related risk factors. The male participants endorsed smoking 20 - 25 cigarettes per day and had started smoking by ages 15 to 18 years. Most of the patients were unaware of lung cancer. The majority, sixty-five participants (76.5%), chews betel quid nut and Jorda. Jorda is a burnt smokeless tobacco. Only five (5.9%) people visited the dentist. Twenty (23.5%) people suffered from oozing and pus in the mouth and twenty-five (29.4%) of the participants had oral and tooth pain.
Only 29.4% of women used sanitary napkins and the remainder used dirty rags. Only five of the eight-five women (5.9%) had received any form of cervical cancer screening. Twenty-three percent and almost six percent of women experienced miscarriage and/or abortions, respectively, in their lifetime. Thirty-five
Table 4. Prevalence of cancer related risk factors of 85 Rohingya Participants in the Kutupalong Refugee camp in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar
percent of women had used contraceptives. During the interview process, women volunteered additional information about their experiences with intimate partner violence. One of the female beneficiary complained pain after experiencing physical violation from her husband. All seventy-five women participants stated that being beaten by their husbands was a normal phenomenon.
Figure 1 shows menopausal age of the female participants. Ten (11.8%) were menopausal and the average age of menopause was 43 years.
The prevalence of infectious disease was much higher than non-communicable diseases among Rohingya refugees (Figure 2). While fifteen (17.6%) participants admitted to tobacco use, thirty-five (41.2%) endorsed a history of asthma, bronchitis, and/or tuberculosis. The participants also noted that other family members were suffering from asthma and other lung diseases. Table 5 represents the pain presentation among the Rohingya participants. Thirty-five (41.2%) people complained of overall body ache and fifteen (17.6%) people presented with severe pain.
Figure 1. Menopausal age of the Rohingya Women Participants in the Kutupalong Refugee camp in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar.
Figure 2. Disease frequency among the 85 Rohingya Participants in the Kutupalong Refugee camp in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar.
Table 5. Pain presentation and pain intensity of 85 Rohingya Participants in the Kutupalong Refugee camp in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar.
4. Interventions
Educational sessions about cancer risks and signs and symptoms of oral, lung, breast, and cervical cancer were given after each interview. A training session on Self Breast Examination was done and the feedback was positive. After instruction and demonstration, the women participants could demonstrate how to do the examination.
5. Discussion
The Rohingya refugee population experienced a long and documented experience of deprivation in Myanmar that encompassed education, healthcare, and economic instability [13] [14]. The consequence of this systematic neglect of basic human rights has led to a population with little formal education, lack of preventative healthcare, and severe poverty. In the refugee camps of Bangladesh, 54% of the population is below the age of 18 [15].
The overall focus of the health sector in the Rohingya refugee camps is on emergency response, communicable diseases, maternal and child care, and community health [4]. Resources have improved in the registered Rohingya populations of the refugee camps. There is antenatal coverage for 94% of the population and close to 100% of births are attended by skilled birth attendants. However there is a scarcity with four trained doctors, four trained nurses, and trained sixteen community health workers per a population of 13,000 [16]. While 33,131 refugees are registered, another 80,000 undocumented refugees live in makeshift camps in the Cox’s Bazar region. These undocumented refugees do not receive the same health benefits as those in the camps [17].
A 2018 rapid needs assessment of 1828 individuals in 402 Rohingya refugee households identified education, poverty, and access to healthcare as crucial needs [6]. The mean Rohingya household size was four people, with the average age of 20 years and with 51% being female. An average of 14% of Rohingya families reported difficulty accessing healthcare due to distances, finances, or other reasons and over 73% of pregnant women delivered at home without a certified birth attendant [6]. Both children and adolescent girls need nutritional support [15]. A cross-sectional study identified 24% of children from ages 6 months to 59 months with global acute malnutrition [18]. Language is an additional barrier to care [19]. Refugees also lack health literacy.
In the two major camps of Kutupalong and Nayapara, crude mortality rate per 1000 per month was 0.2 and 0.4 respectively [14]. Among a population of 913,316 Rohingya refugees in Cox’s Bazar District, there were 135 mortalities in a 12-week period [4]. Twenty-six percent of these deaths were women of reproductive age, stillbirths, and neonatal deaths. The average age of female mortalities was 45.3 years and 35.5 years for male deaths. Seventy-six percent of deaths reported occurred at home. The actual cause of death was not known in 70% of cases. The crude death rate is of 14.7 over 3 months [20]. Overall, Rohingya households experienced 78 deaths in the preceding twelve months compared to 16 deaths among the host households [6].
Infectious and communicable diseases have been the leading cause of illness among the Rohingya refugees. Communicable diseases are an immediate concern and tuberculosis is a major concern. Myanmar was ranked among the top 30 countries for tuberculosis in 2016 [21]. Less than 61 percent of children less than age 2 years had received the nine recommended injectable vaccines and the four oral vaccines in Myanmar and less than 42% of children under age four had received any of these vaccines. Measles outbreaks occurred among new arrivals with a report of 419 cases [22]. 5800 cases of Diphtheria were reported in February 2018 [23]. Risks of communicable diseases were related to access to clean water and latrines. Water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) services were reported to only reach 30% of the refugee population in 2018 [15].
Communicable diseases in Kutupalong and Nayapara camps ranged from 33% to 17% for upper respiratory tract infections; 11.6% to 17.9% for lower respiratory tract infections; 7% to 9% for diarrheal disease, and 11% to 12% for skin infections [14]. Non-communicable diseases are a concern such as chronic pulmonary disease from exposures to indoor cooking fires with poor ventilation and kidney and liver toxins from exposures to polluted waters.
Non-communicable respiratory disorders ranged from 30% to 47%; endocrine disorders 30% to 21%, and cardiovascular disease 19% to 15% respectively. Refugees suffered from treatment resistant tuberculosis (21%), pain (73%), insomnia (56%), cough (55%), anorexia (45%), and dyspnea (39%) [24].
Among the Rohingya refugees, severe physical disabilities from violence and injuries (63%) are more common than cancer (10%) [24]. 89.5% of residents in Kutupalong and 64% of residents in Nayapara experience injuries from accidents [14].
Sexually transmitted infections are prevalent because of a high baseline rate in Myanmar, sexual assault of Rohingya women, and sexual exploitation of women in the refugee camps [25] [26].
One in seven Rohingya women in Northern Rakhine state had undergone at least one unskilled abortion in unhygienic conditions [27].
Life-limiting illness and mortality occur from the consequences of violence, malnutrition, maternal mortality, infectious diseases, non-communicable diseases and cancers. Disabilities increase in the setting of poverty, food insecurity, lack of employment and lack of education with an estimated 18% of the Rohingya refugee population challenged by disability [16].
Preventable cancers include those that are sexually transmitted from human papilloma virus infections and environmentally induced cancers from pollutants and tobacco products. Other preventable cancers are those that can be detected early with appropriate screening such as skin cancers, breast, prostate, colon, and cervical cancers. Cervical cancer risk has a two-fold increased risk for women exposed to early sexual debut at ages 14 to 15 years and multiple sexual partners compared to women without those exposures [28]. Oral cancers are common in South Asia due to Betel nut and tobacco chewing and carry only a fifty percent survival [10].
Our rapid situational analysis of 85 people confirmed the findings of other investigators. We identified that cancer risk factors of lack of awareness, screening, poor hygiene and exposure to carcinogens are present in the Rohingya refugee community.
In our study 82.4% respondents were not familiar with the term lung cancer, only 29.4% knew about breast cancer, 11.8% understood the term cervical cancer, and 55.9% were familiar with the term oral cancer.
6. Limitations
Since we visited the camp for a really very short period of time, sample size may be insufficient to represent total FDMN Rohingya population.
7. Conclusions and Recommendation
Kutupalong is a refugee camp in Ukhiya, Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh inhabited by Rohingyas who fled from ethnic and religious persecution in neighboring Myanmar. Extreme poverty, lack of resources and poor health services are contributing factors towards acute and chronic diseases.
The Rohingya refugees lack knowledge about cancer risk factors, and cancer symptoms.
This community needs education about preventable cancers and its early symptoms. The session of Self Breast Examination (SBE) helped the participants to learn about screening. Most of the people are smokers and use betel nut with jorda, which is very harmful for lungs, and can also cause oral cancer. Interventions to reduce smoking and betel quid chewing are very important in the community. Forty-one percent of participants experienced pain. Pain relief and palliation of symptoms should be additional resources at the health facility.
Acknowledgements
We are very grateful to Refugee repartition rehabilitation commission for allowing us to do the short survey. We are also grateful to ACI conglomerate for supporting us with the survey.
Funding
This research did not receive any funding in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.