Tumour Associated Tissue Eosinophilia as a Prognostic Indicator in Squamous Cell Carcinoma of Upper Aerodigestive Tract ()
Received 27 August 2015; accepted 5 March 2016; published 8 March 2016
1. Introduction
Inflammatory infiltration with eosinophil as a result of immune reaction against tumour antigen in or around the tumoural tissue varies among the cases with squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of upper aero digestive tract. The aim of this study was to investigate and evaluate the possible role of the tumour associated tissue eosinophilia (TATE) as a predictive indicator for the grading and establishing prognosis of the upper aerodigestive tract squamous cell carcinoma (SCC).
In our study 58 cases of squamous cell carcinoma involving oral cavity, pharynx and larynx except nose and nasopharynx were biopsied in department of ENT and Head, Neck Surgery, MLB Medical College, Jhansi (INDIA) for the evaluation of tumour associated tissue eosinophilia. The study is based on the tissue eosinophil count per 10 high power field and cases were grouped into 3 GRADES-I, II and III.
Various parameters were taken to establish possible prognostic indicators for squamous cell carcinoma. Clinically the most significant indicators are TNM classification and lymph node metastasis classification [1] [2] . Predictive histopathologic parameters are borders of tumour and grading of the tumour and cytological parameter in predicting the prognosis is tumour associated tissue eosinophilia [1] [2] . The tumour with pushing border and broad cords of cells have better prognosis whereas tumours which invade as single cells or small irregular cords (non-pushing) have relatively poor prognosis [3] .
Squamous cell carcinoma is classified into 3 histopathological grades-well differentiated, moderately differentiated and poorly differentiated based on nuclear atypia and keratinisation [4] . Tissue eosinophilia is known to be associated with a number of neoplasm’s [5] .
Clinical correlative studies of patients with tissue eosinophilia have suggested that tissue eosinophilia can be protective in tumours and plays as a good prognostic indicator [5] . The study demonstrated positive correlation between the tumours associated tissue eosinophilia and the prognosis of the cancer.
2. Methods and Materials
All the patients under study were biopsied after taking informed consent and detailed history and clinical examination. Histopathological specimen was studied regarding differentiation of tumour, infiltration of eosinophil and nature of borders. Tissue eosinophils were counted in randomly chosen 10 high power field in slides prepared with haematoxylin and eosin staining and were classified into three GRADES:
Tumour associated tissue eosinophilia correlate with the immune status of the patient. Patient with better immune status shows better cellular immune reaction to tumour and leads to more infiltration of eosinophils and points towards favourable prognosis. Biopsied specimens were also examined for the nature of the borders and cords. Borders are classified into the following types:
1) Large pushing borders and broad cords (pushing border)
2) Borders invading as single cell or small cords (non-pushing border)
Squamous cell carcinoma is also classified into 3 grades based on the degree of keratinisation and nuclear atypia namely:
1) Well differentiated SCC
2) Moderately differentiated SCC
3) Poorly differentiated SCC
In our study, the histopathological findings like borders, grading and cytological indicator tumour associated tissue eosinophilia were analysed as prognostic indicator for the squamous cell carcinoma of upper aero digestive tract including oral cavity, pharynx and larynx except nose and nasopharynx.
3. Observation
The biopsied specimens of 58 patients having squamous cell carcinoma of upper aerodigestive tract including oral cavity, pharynx and larynx except nose and nasopharynx were studied. Out of them 50 were male and 8 were female with the male: female was 6:1, belonged to the age group ranging from 25 years to 80 years (Table 1).
35 (60.34%) cases were having oral cavity SCC, 13 (22.41%) cases were having pharynx SCC and 10 (17.24%) cases were having larynx SCC (Table 2).
![]()
Table 1. Showing distribution of sex among cases.
![]()
Table 2. Showing distribution of site among cases.
In our study 23 cases were having well differentiated SCC, 32 were having moderately differentiated SCC and 3 cases were having poorly differentiated SCC. All 23 cases with well differentiated SCC were having pushing borders, 2 were having grade I TATE, 6 were having grade II TATE and 15 were having grade III TATE. All 32 cases with moderately differentiated SCC were having pushing borders, 5 were having grade I TATE, 22 were having grade II TATE and 5 were having grade III TATE. All 3 cases with poorly differentiated SCC were having non pushing borders and grade I TATE (Table 3).
4. Discussion
Leighton defined TATE as the “tumoral infiltration by eosinophils not related to the presence of necrosis and/or ulceration”; although, the definition was arbitrary and poorly defined.
The studies by Goldsmith et al., in 1987 [6] and in 1992 [7] , Thompson et al., in 1994 [8] , Nielsen et al., in 1999 [9] , Fernández Aceñero et al., in 2000 [10] and Dorta et al., in 2002 have established TATE with a favourable prognosis while the studies by Horiuchi et al., in 1993 [11] , Van Driel et al., in1999 [12] and Wong et al., in 1999 [13] were associated with an unfavourable prognosis of TATE and some studies like Looi, in 1987 [14] ; Sassler et al., in 1995 [15] have shown no influence on the prognosis.
In the head and neck SCC, it has been reported that the presence of tissue eosinophils ranges from 22% to 89%. According to Said M, Wiseman S, Yang J, Alrawi S, Douglas W, Cheney R, et al. TATE is a tissue morphologic marker for assessing stromal invasion in laryngeal squamous neoplasms. In our study, TATE was present in 86% (43 out of 50) cases, which is in accordance with other studies. Deron et al. in their study to evaluate TATE kept the cut-off of eosinophil infiltration at 2 eos/hpf [16] . Goldsmith et al., in their study, segregated eosinophilic infiltration within 4 categories of progressive increasing count, the highest being categorized as 4+, that is, more than 30 eos/hpf [6] [7] . Said et al. in their study, evaluated 87 cases of invasive SCC and preinvasive squamous neoplasia and segregated the elevated eosinophils as: Focally and moderately elevated (59 eos/hpf), focally and markedly increased (>10/hpf), diffusely and moderately elevated (519 eos/10 hpf) and diffusely and markedly increased (>20/10 hpf) [17] .
In our study, we categorized and graded the elevated eosinophil count as I with 0 - 20 cells/10 hpf, II with 21 - 40 cells/10 hpf and III with more than 40 cells/10 hpf. Amirala Aghbali et al. in their study on Tumour-associ- ated Tissue and Blood Eosinophils in Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma found that Eosinophil counts in tissue samples revealed positive correlation with tumour grade without positive relation with tumour size and lymph node involvement. These findings are consistent with some studies and in contrast to some others. Priya Shirish Joshi et al. underwent histochemical study of tissue eosinophilia in oral squamous cell carcinoma using Congo red staining showed 36 (83.72%) cases were found to have elevated diffuse eosinophilic infiltration out of which 21 (48.83%) were severely elevated, 13 (30.23%) were moderately elevated and 2 (4.65%) were mildly elevated. Only 7 (16.27%) cases showed focal eosinophilic infiltration out of which 4 were severely elevated and 3 were mildly elevated.
In our current study, we classified the TATE infiltration into three grades I, II and III and the number of cases showing grade I is 10 (17.2%), grade II is 28 (48.3%) and grade III is 20 (34.5%). Our study also shows with advancing age patient immune status become poorer and TATE declines.
![]()
Table 3. Showing differentiation of tumour and histological parameter.
5. Conclusions
Ø Incidence of SCC of upper aerodigestive region is more in male as compared to female.
Ø Oral cavity is the most common site of SCC of upper aerodigestive region.
Pushing border and higher eosinophil count were associated with favourable prognosis.