Nanoindentation Study on Mechanical Properties of Nano-SiO2/Dental Resin Composites


The micro/nano-scale indentation tests were performed to explore the performance of bisphenol-α-glycidyl methacrylate (Bis-GMA)/triethylene glycol dimethacrylate (TEGDMA) dental resin composites. The effect of the filling content of nano-SiO2 particles on the mechanical properties of the dental composites was studied as well. The experimental results showed that the incorporation of the nano-SiO2 particles at low concentrations (up to 10 wt.%) can apparently increase the hardness and elastic modulus of the dental rein composites. The plasticity index indicates a best elastic recovery capability at a proper amount (4 wt.%) of the nanoparticles. Combined with the infrared spectrum, the mechanical enhancement mechanisms of the dental resin composites were analyzed.

Share and Cite:

Zha, C. , Hu, J. , Li, A. , Huang, S. , Liu, H. , Chen, G. , Lei, A. , Zhang, Z. , Li, B. and Wang, Z. (2018) Nanoindentation Study on Mechanical Properties of Nano-SiO2/Dental Resin Composites. Journal of Materials Science and Chemical Engineering, 6, 57-64. doi: 10.4236/msce.2018.64008.

1. Introduction

Dental resin composites have been widely used for restoring dental defects and caries instead of conventional metallic dental amalgam due to their sufficient strength, superior biocompatibility, and excellent esthetics [1] [2]. Resin composites generally consist of a polymeric matrix involving visible-light-cured bisphenol-α-glycidyl methacrylate (Bis-GMA), diluted with agent triethylene glycol dimethacrylate (TEGDMA). Meanwhile, inorganic macro/micro-fillers (e.g., barium glass powder (BG), SiO2, Al2O3, ZrO2) are incorporated with organic matrix by light curable technique to increase mechanical properties of the matrix [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]. Although inorganic fillers have been mixed into composite resin matrix to enhance the strength, toughness and wear resistance of the dental resins, there are still some issues in dental restorations, processing and biocompatibility. Recent research has led to the development of nano-fillers to reinforce the mechanical properties of the composites by regulating filler size, shape and compositions [8] [9] [10]. Promising consequences of applying nano-fillers include reducing polymerization shrinkage, improving mechanical properties such as toughness and flexure strength, and ensuring good biocompatibility and comfort level at the same time [11] [12].

In recent years, indentation at ultra-microscopic level has drawn broad attention in characterizing mechanical properties of metals, ceramics, polymers and biomolecules [13] [14]. Micro/nano-indentaion allows accurate determination and control of the indentation force and accurate measurement of the indentation depth. The mechanical properties (e.g., hardness and modulus) can be obtained directly from simultaneous indentation load-displacement curves. However, the studies of nano-filled dental resin composites using indentation at micro/nano-scale were still limited. The present paper aims to examine the mechanical properties of the dental resin composites with various nano-SiO2 particle content using nano-mechanics testing system. The detailed analysis in this work is believed to provide an experimental insight into Bis-GMA/TEGDMA dental resin composites at micro/nano-scale.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Materials

The dental restoration matrix consisted of 70 wt.% Bis-GMA and 30 wt.% viscosity-modifying TEGDMA obtained from BOC sciences, USA. The photoini- tiator camphorquinone (CQ) (0.2 wt.%) and the amine reducing agent ethyl 4-dimethylaminoben-zoate (EDAB) (0.8 wt.%) were added to help trigger the photo-polymerization process when exposed to radiation. The silanized nano- SiO2 particles were then incorporated into the matrix with an average diameter of 20 nm and varying SiO2 contents: 0 wt.%, 2 wt.%, 4 wt.%, 6 wt.%, 8 wt.%, and 10 wt.%. All the samples were stirred for about 3 minutes using the high speed centrifuge to ensure the spherical nanoparticles were dispersed homogenously in the composite matrix. After that, they were irradiated for 180 s under the visible blue light with an irradiation flux of 1000 mV/cm3. According to the content of the nanoparticle filler, the samples were designated as S0, S2, S4, S6, S8, and S10, respectively.

2.2. Indentation Tests

The mechanical properties of the dental resin composites were investigated by micro/nano-scale indentation tests. All the tests were performed using the commercially available Triboindenter system (Hysitron USA T-950) with a diamond equilateral triangular indenter (Berkovich). This instrument provides accurate automated testing for the mechanical properties at micro/nano-scale and high resolution real-time imaging of surfaces. The load resolutionis 1 nN and displacement resolution is 0.0002 nm.

The indentation tests were carried out in quasi-static force-control mode, in which the applied force is controlled in a pre-programmed manner and the displacement continuously monitored. The loading function of all the indentations in this work consisted of a 5−s linear loading and 5−s unloading segment together with a 10−s holding at the peak load of 8 mN. This kind of loading could reduce the influence of the creeping effect [15] and its schematics is presented in Figure 1. The hardness and modulus could be obtained according to the load-dis- placement curve based on the Oliver and Pharr’s method [14]. The final values of hardness and modulus data were calculated as the average of 6 distinct regions on each sample surface. Each region was again marked by and calculated as a mean of 12 spots with a spacing of 40 μm either in parallel or perpendicular direction to eliminate mutual influences.

3. Results and Discussions

3.1. Hardness and Moduus

Figure 2 shows the typical load-displacement curves of the S0, S2, S8, and S10, from which we can clearly see that the hmax (maximum indentation depth) decreases gradually with the increasing filler content. At the peak load, the hmax of S0 is about 300 nm more than that of S10, which implies that the dental resins reinforced with nano-silica particles exhibits much larger hardness than the free

Figure 1. Schematics of the loading functionduring the indentation test.

Figure 2. Load-displacement curves of S0, S2, S8, and S10 during the indentation.

one. However, the loading and unloading segments of the image possess steeper slopes with the increasing filler content. During the unloading process, the samples underwent elastic recovery and presented a decreasing hir (irreversible indentation depth) as the concentration of the nanoparticles increases. Especially for each increment (2 wt.%) in the filler content, hirhas the largest decrease of 71 nm from S0 to S2, which shows that the nano-SiO2 particles can greatly improve the mechanical properties of dental resin composites even at low filler contents.

Figure 3 shows the results of hardness H and modulus E for different filler content. It can be seen that both H and E increase monotonously with the nanoparticle content. Hardness and modulusrise from 0.126 and 3.15 GPa of S0 to 0.208 and 4.09 GPa of S10, with an increment of 65% and 30%, respectively. The apparent increase in H and E is mainly due to two reasons. Firstly, the nano-SiO2 particles have much higher H and E, and the resulting mixing effect of the dental resin matrix and the particles can lead to improvement of H and E of dental resin/SiO2 composites. Secondly, the incorporation of nanoparticles can enhance the load-carrying capacity and inhibit the formation of internal micro-cracks based on the strong particle-matrix bonding, thereby improving the mechanical properties [3].

3.2. Plasticity Index

The plasticity index, which describes the relative plastic/elastic behavior of the material effectively when it undergoes external stresses and strains. The results of the plasticity index φ as a function of the filler particle content is shown in Figure 4(a). Figure 4(b) shows the schematics of the calculation of plasticity index and it is defined as [16]

φ = W i r / ( W i r + W r ) (1)

where W i r and W r represent the irreversible work done during indentation and the reversible work recovered by viscoelastic processes during unloading,

Figure 3. Hardness H and Elastic modulus Eversus particle filler content for dental resin composites.

(a) (b)

Figure 4. (a) Plasticity index versus particle filler content and (b) The schematics of calculation of plasticity index.

respectively. From Figure 4(a), we can find that the plasticity index decrease initiallywith the nano-SiO2 particle content from 0 wt.% to 4 wt.%, and then increases afterward when the filler mass ratio increases from 4 wt.% to 10 wt.%. A larger plasticity index meansmore plastic deformation proportion, therefore the dental resin composite with 4 wt.% nano-SiO2 particles exhibits the best elastic recovery in the indentation process.

3.3. Infrared Test

The Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) profiles of the samples S0, S2 and S6 are shown in Figure 5. Through the spectrogram, we can see that the characteristicabsorption peak for the carbonyl C=O is located at the wavenumber of 1726 cm1, and those for the aliphatic C=C and aromatic C=C

Figure 5. Fourier transform infrared spectrogram of the dental resin composites.

are at around 1638 cm1 and 1582 cm1, and the stretch vibration absorption for the esteryl C-O is found at around 1182 cm1, 1249 cm1 and 1297 cm1, respectively. It is also shown that the transmittance of the S6 sample is much lower than S0 at the whole frequency range, indicating that the dental resin composite with nano-SiO2 particles possesses a higher crystallinity than the standalone one. More importantly, the crystallinity increases with the filler content. For polymer-based composites, the incorporated nanoparticles play roles as the nucleating agents during crystallization. With the nuclei, compact and fine spherulite particles can be formed in the polymeric matrix, and the hybrid composite exhibits microcrystalline structure, causing increased crystal- linity [17]. For the dental resin composites, the nano-SiO2 particles are used as the crystal nuclei and have a positive effect on the crystallization process of the resin matrix. This leads to improved filler-matrix coupling and thus contributes to increased mechanical performance, i.e., the hardness and modulus, of the resin/nano-SiO2 composites as the filler content increases.

4. Summary

In this work, the mechanical performance of the dental resin composites incorporated with nano-SiO2 particles (20 nm) were investigated via micro/ nano-scale indentation tests. The incoprorationof nano-SiO2 particles (10 wt.%) can greatly enhance the hardness and elastic modulus of the Bis-GMA/ TEGDMA dental composites, with an increment of 65% and 30%, respectively. Moreover, the elastic recovery was characterized by the plasticity index and it revealed that the dental resin composites with 4 wt.% nano-SiO2 particles exhibit the best elastic recovery behavior. Finally, the reinforcement mechanism of the nano-SiO2/resin composites was evaluated. The nano-SiO2 particles act as the nucleating agents during the crystallization process of the dental composite matrix, causing increased crystallinity and improved mechanical properties. It is believed that the findings in this study provide micro/nano-scale insights into the mechanical performance of dental resin composites.


The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (11602177 and 51603160), the Funda- mental Research Funds for the Central Universities (WUT: 173201001), the Natural Science Foundation of Hubei Province (2016CFB248), and the Open Fund Project of State Key Laboratory of Materials Processing and Die & Mould Technology, Huazhong University of Science and Technology (P2017-011).

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.


[1] Maffezzoli, A., Pietra, A.D., Rengo, S., Nicolais, L. and Valletta, G. (1994) Photopolymerization of Dental Composite Matrices. Biomaterials, 15, 1221-1228.
[2] Fleming, M.G. and Maillet, W.A. (1999) Photopolymerization of Compositeresin Using the Argon Laser. J. Can. Dent. Assoc, 65, 447-450.
[3] Hosseinalipour, M., Javadpour, J., Rezaie, H., Dadras, T. and Hayati, A.N. (2010) Investigation of Mechanical Properties of Experimental Bis-Gma/Tegdma Dental Composite Resins Containing Various Mass Fractions of Silica Nanoparticles. J. Prosthodont, 19, 112-117.
[4] Alsharif, S.O., Akil, H.B.M., El-Aziz, N.A.A. and Ahmad, Z.A.B. (2014) Effect of Alumina Particles Loading on the Mechanical Properties of Light-Cured Dental Resin Composites. Mater. Design, 54, 430-435.
[5] Aguiar, A.E., Silva, L.G.D., Barbosa, H.F.D.P., Glória, R.F., Soares, M.E. and Rossano, G. (2017) Synthesis of Al2O3-0.5B2O3-SiO2 Fillers by Sol-Gel Method for Dental Resin Composites. J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 458, 86-96.
[6] Atsu, S.S., Kilicarslan, M.A., Kucukesmen, H.C. and Aka, P.S. (2006) Effect of Zirconium-Oxide Ceramic Surface Treatments on the Bond Strength to Adhesive Resin. J. Prosthet. Dent., 95, 430-436.
[7] Smith, R.L., Villanueva, C., Rothrock, J.K., Garcia-Godoy, C.E., Stoner, B.R., Piascik, J.R. and Thompson, J.Y. (2011) Long-Term Microtensile Bond Strength of Surface Modified Zirconia. Dent. Mater, 27, 779-785.
[8] Masouras, K., Akhtar, R., Watts, D.C. and Silikas, N. (2008) Effect of Filler Size and Shape on Local Nanoindentation Modulus of Resin-Composites. J. Mater. Sci. Mater. Med, 19, 3561-3566.
[9] Bindu, M.G., Satapathy, B.K., Jaggi, H.S. and Ray, A.R. (2013) Size-Scale Effects of Silica on Bis-Gma/Tegdma Based Nanohybrid Dental Restorative Composites. Compos. Part B-Eng, 53, 92-102.
[10] Kaleem, M., Satterthwaite, J.D. and Watts, D.C. (2009) Effect of Filler Particle Size and Morphology on Force/Work Parameters for Stickiness of Unset Resin-Composites. Dent. Ma-ter, 25, 1585-1592.
[11] Wang, X., Cai, Q., Zhang, X., Wei, Y., Xu, M., Yang, X., Ma, Q., Cheng, Y. and Deng, X. (2016) Improved Performance of Bis-Gma/Tegdma Dental Composites by Net-Like Structures Formed from SiO2 Nanofiber Fillers. Mater. Sci. Eng. C. Mater. Biol. Appl., 59, 464-470.
[12] Kaleem, M., Satterthwaite, J.D. (2012) Watts, Effect of Filler Size and Morphology on Viscoelastic Stability of Resin-Composites under Dynamic Loading. J. Mater. Sci. Mater. Med, 23, 623-627.
[13] Barrioz, J.C., Mazuyer, D., Tonck, A. and Kapsa, P.H. (2006) Chateauminois, Nanoscratch and Friction: An Innovative Approach to Understand the Tribological Behaviour of Poly(Amide) Fibres. Tribol. Int, 39, 62-69.
[14] Oliver, W.C. and Pharr, G.M. (2004) Measurement of Hardness and Elastic Modulus by Instrumented Indentation: Advances in Understanding and Refinements to Methodology. J. Mater. Res, 19, 3-20.
[15] Briscoe, B.J., Fiori, L. and Pelillo, E. (1998) Nano-Indentation of Polymeric Surfaces. J. Phys, 31, 2395-2405.
[16] Powles, R.C., Mckenzie, D.R., Meure, S.J. and Swain, M.V. (2007) Nanoindentation Response of PEEK Modified by Mesh-Assisted Plasma Immersion Ion Implantation. Surf. Coat. Tech, 201, 7961-7969.
[17] Pramoda, K.P., Mohamed, A., Phang, I.Y. and Liu, T.X. (2005) Crystal Transformation and Thermomechanical Properties of Poly (Vinylidene Fluoride)/Clay Nanocomposites. Polym. Int, 54, 226-232.

Copyright © 2021 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.