Causality Is Logically Definable—Toward an Equilibrium-Based Computing Paradigm of Quantum Agent and Quantum Intelligence (QAQI) (Survey and Research)


A survey on agents, causality and intelligence is presented and an equilibrium-based computing paradigm of quantum agents and quantum intelligence (QAQI) is proposed. In the survey, Aristotle’s causality principle and its historical extensions by David Hume, Bertrand Russell, Lotfi Zadeh, Donald Rubin, Judea Pearl, Niels Bohr, Albert Einstein, David Bohm, and the causal set initiative are reviewed; bipolar dynamic logic (BDL) is introduced as a causal logic for bipolar inductive and deductive reasoning; bipolar quantum linear algebra (BQLA) is introdused as a causal algebra for quantum agent interaction and formation. Despite the widely held view that causality is undefinable with regularity, it is shown that equilibrium-based bipolar causality is logically definable using BDL and BQLA for causal inference in physical, social, biological, mental, and philosophical terms. This finding leads to the paradigm of QAQI where agents are modeled as quantum enssembles; intelligence is revealed as quantum intelligence. It is shown that the enssemble formation, mutation and interaction of agents can be described as direct or indirect results of quantum causality. Some fundamental laws of causation are presented for quantum agent entanglement and quantum intelligence. Applicability is illustrated; major challenges are identified in equilibriumbased causal inference and quantum data mining.

Share and Cite:

Zhang, W. and Peace, K. (2014) Causality Is Logically Definable—Toward an Equilibrium-Based Computing Paradigm of Quantum Agent and Quantum Intelligence (QAQI) (Survey and Research). Journal of Quantum Information Science, 4, 227-268. doi: 10.4236/jqis.2014.44021.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.


[1] Hume, D. (1738) A Treatise of Human Nature. Norton, D.F. and Norton, M.J., Eds., Oxford University Press, Oxford/ New York.
[2] Hume, D. (1748) An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. Renascence Editions.
[3] Blackburn, S. (1990) Hume and Thick Connexions. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 50, 237-250.
[4] Russell, B. (1913) On the Notion of Cause. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 13, 1-26.
[5] Bohr, N. (1948) On The Notions of Causality and Complementarity. Dialectica, 2, 312-319.
[6] Zadeh, L.A. (2001) Causality Is Undefinable—Toward a Theory of Hierarchical Definability. The 10th IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems, 2-5 December 2001, 67-68.
[7] Zadeh, L.A. (2008) Fuzzy Logic. Scholarpedia, 3, 1766.
[8] Zhang, W.-R. (1998) YinYang Bipolar Fuzzy Sets. Proceedings of IEEE World Congress on Computational Intelligence, Anchorage, May 1998, 835-840.
[9] Zhang, W.-R. (2011) YinYang Bipolar Relativity: A Unifying Theory of Nature, Agents and Causality with Applications in Quantum Computing, Cognitive Informatics and Life Sciences. IGI Global, Hershey and New York.
[10] Smolin, L. (2006) The Trouble with Physics: The Rise of String Theory, the Fall of a Science, and What Comes Next? Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, New York.
[11] Woit, P. (2006) Not Even Wrong: The Failure of String Theory and the Search for Unity in Physical Law. Basic Book, New York, 2006.
[12] Bub, J. (2006) Quantum Entanglement and Information. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
[13] Bell, J.S. (1964) On the Einstein Podolsky Rosen Paradox. Physics, 1, 195-200.
[14] Hawking, S. and Penrose, R. (1970) The Singularities of Gravitational Collapse and Cosmology. Proceedings of the Royal Society A, 314, 529-548.
[15] Hawking, S. (1974) Black Hole Evaporation. Nature, 248, 30-31.
[16] Hawking, S. (1975) Particle Creation by Black Holes. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 43, 199-220.
[17] Cazalilla, M.A. and Rigol, M. (2010) Focus on Dynamics and Thermalization in Isolated Quantum Many-Body Systems. New Journal of Physics, 12, Article ID: 055006.
[18] Falcon, A. (2008) Aristotle on Causality. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
[19] Morris, W.E. (2009) David Hume. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. entries/hume/
[20] Russell, B. (1948) Human Knowledge. Simon & Schuster, New York.
[21] Russell, B. (1945) A History of Western Philosophy. Simon & Schuster, New York.
[22] Lewis, D. (1973) Causation. Journal of Philosophy, 70, 556-567.
[23] Mackie, J.L. (1974) The Cement of the Universe. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
[24] Von Wright, G.H. (1975) On the Logic and Epistemology of the Causal Relation. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 95-113.
[25] Rorty, R. (1989) Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[26] Russell, B. (1919) Introduction to Mathematical Philosophy. Routledge Inc., London.
[27] Rubin, D. (1974) Estimating Causal Effects of Treatments in Randomized and Nonrandomized Studies. Journal of Educational Psychology, 66, 688-701.
[28] Rubin, D. (1978) Bayesian Inference for Causal Effects: The Role of Randomization. The Annals of Statistics, 6, 34-58.
[29] Rosenbaum, P. and Rubin, D. (1983) The Central Role of the Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects. Biometrika, 70, 41-55.
[30] Pearl, J. (1988) Probabilistic Reasoning in Intelligent Systems: Networks of Plausible Inference. Morgan Kaufmann Publishers, San Mateo, 1988.
[31] Pearl, J. (2000) Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
[32] Pearl, J. (2009) Causal Analysis in Theory and Practice—More on Pearl’s and Robin’s Frameworks for Causal Inference— Discussion.
[33] Zhang, W.-R. (2013) Bipolar Quantum Logic Gates and Quantum Cellular Combinatorics—A Logical Extension to Quantum Entanglement. Journal of Quantum Information Science, 3, 93-105.
[34] Ben-Menahem, Y. (1993) Struggling with Causality: Einstein’s Case. Science in Context, 6, 291-310.
[35] Einstein, A., Podolsky, B. and Rosen, N. (1935) Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete? Physical Review, 47, 777-780.
[36] Einstein, A. (1916) The Foundation of the General Theory of Relativity. Annalen der Physik, 49, 769-822.
[37] Einstein, A. (1934) On the Method of Theoretical Physics. The Herbert Spencer Lecture, Mein Weltbild, Querido Verlag, Amsterdam.
[38] Einstein, A. (1940) Considerations Concerning the Fundaments of Theoretical Physics. Science, 91, 487-491.
[39] Einstein, A. (1953) Famous Letter to J. E. Switzer. [cf. de Solla Price, D. (1963) Science since Babylon. Yale University Press, New Haven, 15, Note 10.]
[40] Bohm, D. (1980) Wholeness and the Implicate Order. Routledge, London.
[41] Bohm, D. (1957) Causality and Chance in Modern Physics. Routledge & Kegan Paul and D. Van Nostrand.
[42] Bell, J.S. (1964) On the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Paradox. Physics, 1, 195-200.
[43] Kumar, M. (2008) Quantum: Einstein, Bohr, and the Great Debate about the Nature of Reality. Norton & Company, New York, London.
[44] Bombelli, L., Lee, J., Meyer, D. and Sorkin, R.D. (1987) Spacetime as a Causal Set. Physical Review Letters, 59, 521-524.
[45] Malament, D. (1977) The Class of Continuous Timelike Curves Determines the Topology of Spacetime. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 18, 1399-1404.
[46] Dowker, F., Henson, J. and Sorkin, R. (2004) Quantum Gravity Phenomenology, Lorentz Invariance and Discreteness. Modern Physics Letters A, 19, 1829-1840.
[47] Dowker, F. (2006) Causal Sets as Discrete Spacetime. Contemporary Physics, 47, 1-9.
[48] Bombelli, L., Henson, J. and Sorkin, R.D. (2009) Discreteness without Symmetry Breaking: A Theorem. Modern Physics Letters A, 24, 2579-2587.
[49] Bombelli, L., Corichi, A. and Winkler, O. (2009) Semiclassical Quantum Gravity: Obtaining Manifolds from Graphs. Classical and Quantum Gravity, 26, Article ID: 245012.
[50] Gottfredson, L.S. (1997) Mainstream Science on Intelligence: An Editorial with 52 Signatories, History, and Bibliography. Intelligence, 24, 13-23.
[51] Neisser, U., Boodoo, G., Bouchard, T.J., Boykin, A.W., Brody, N., Ceci, S.J., Halpern, D.F., Loehlin, J.C., Perloff, R., Sternberg, R.J. and Urbina, S. (1996) Intelligence: Knowns and Unknowns. American Psychologist, 51, 77-101.
[52] Neisser, U., Boodoo, G., Bouchard Jr, T.J., Boykin, A.W., Brody, N., Ceci, S.J., Halpern, D.F., Loehlin, J.C., Perloff, R., Sternberg, R.J., et al. (1998) Intelligence: Knowns and Unknowns. Annual Progress in Child Psychiatry and Child Development, Board of Scientific Affairs of the American Psychological Association.
[53] Ball, P. (2011) Physics of Life: The Dawn of Quantum Biology. Nature, 474, 272-274.
[54] Moran, E. and Yu, J. (2001) The Complete Idiot’s Guide to the I Ching. Alpha Books, New York.
[55] Leibniz, G. (1703) Explication de l’Arithmétique Binaire (Explanation of Binary Arithmetic). Mathematical Writings VII, Gerhardt, 223.
[56] Hawking, S. and Mlodinow, L. (2010) The Grand Design. Random House Digital, Inc., New York.
[57] Zhang, W.-R. (2003) Equilibrium Relations and Bipolar Cognitive Mapping for Online Analytical Processing with Applications in International Relations and Strategic Decision Support. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part B, 33, 295-307.
[58] Zhang, W.-R. (2003) Equilibrium Energy and Stability Measures for Bipolar Decision and Global Regulation. International Journal of Fuzzy Systems, 5, 114-122.
[59] Zhang, W.-R. and Zhang, L. (2004) YinYang Bipolar Logic and Bipolar Fuzzy Logic. Information Sciences, 165, 265-287.
[60] Zhang, W.-R. (2005) YinYang Bipolar Lattices and L-Sets for Bipolar Knowledge Fusion, Visualization, and Decision. International Journal of Information Technology & Decision Making, 4, 621-645.
[61] Zhang, W.-R. (2006) YinYang Bipolar Fuzzy Sets and Fuzzy Equilibrium Relations for Bipolar Clustering, Optimization, and Global Regulation. International Journal of Information Technology & Decision Making, 5, 19-46.
[62] Gore, J. and Van Oudenaarden, A. (2009) Synthetic Biology: The Yin and Yang of Nature. Nature, 457, 271-272.
[63] Shi, Y., Seto, E., Chang, L.-S. and Shenk, T. (1991) Transcriptional Repression by YY1, a Human GLI-Kruppel-Related Protein, and Relief of Repression by Adenovirus E1A Protein. Cell, 67, 377-388.
[64] Ai, W., Narahari, J. and Roman, A. (2000) Yin Yang 1 Negatively Regulates the Differentiation-Specific E1 Promoter of Human Papillomavirus Type 6. Journal of Virology, 74, 5198-5205.
[65] Palko, L., Bass, H.W., Beyrouthy, M.J. and Hurt, M.M. (2004) The Yin Yang-1 (YY1) Protein Undergoes a DNA-Replication-Associated Switch in Localization from the Cytoplasm to the Nucleus at the Onset of S Phase. Journal of Cell Science, 117, 465-476.
[66] Zhou, Q. and Yik, J.H.N. (2006) The Yin and Yang of P-TEFb Regulation: Implications for Human Immunodeficiency Virus Gene Expression and Global Control of Cell Growth and Differentiation. Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews, 70, 646-659.
[67] Wilkinson, F.H., Park, K. and Atchison, M.L. (2006) Polycomb Recruitment to DNA in Vivo by the YY1 REPO Domain. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 103, 19296-19301.
[68] Kim, J.D., Faulk, C. and Kim, J. (2007) Retroposition and Evolution of the DNA-Binding Motifs of YY1, YY2 and REX1. Nucleic Acids Research, 35, 3442-3452.
[69] Santiago, F.S., Ishii, H., Shafi, S., Khurana, R., Kanellakis, P., Bhindi, R., Ramirez, M.J., Bobik, A., Martin, J.F., Chesterman, C.N., Zachary, I.C. and Khachigian, L.M. (2007) Yin Yang-1 Inhibits Vascular Smooth Muscle Cell Growth and Intimal, Thickening by Repressing p21WAF1/Cip1 Transcription and p21WAF1/Cip1-Cdk4-Cyclin D1 Assembly. Circulation Research, 101, 146-155.
[70] Liu, H., Schmidt-Supprian, M., Shi, Y., Hobeika, E., Barteneva, N., Jumaa, H., Pelanda, R., Reth, M., Skok, J., Rajewsky, K. and Shi, Y. (2007) Yin Yang 1 Is a Critical Regulator of B-Cell Development. Genes & Development, 21, 1179-1189.
[71] Vasudevan, S., Tong, Y. and Steitz, J.A. (2007) Switching from Repression to Activation: Micro-RNAs Can Up-Regulate Translation. Science, 318, 1931-1934.
[72] Zhang, W.-R., Pandurangi, A. and Peace, K. (2007) YinYang Dynamic Neurobiological Modeling and Diagnostic Analysis of Major Depressive and Bipolar Disorders. IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, 54, 1729-1739.
[73] Zhang, W.-R., Pandurangi, K.A., Peace, K.E., Zhang, Y. and Zhao, Z. (2011) Mental Squares—A Generic Bipolar Support Vector Machine for Psychiatric Disorder Classification, Diagnostic Analysis and Neurobiological Data Mining. International Journal on Data Mining and Bioinformatics, 5, 532-557.
[74] Valk, P.E., Bailey, D.L., Townsend, D.W. and Maisey, M.N. (2005) Positron Emission Tomography: Basic Sciences. Springer-Verlag, Secaucus.
[75] Carey, B. (2007) Man Regains Speech after Brain Stimulation. The New York Times—Health.
[76] Zhang, W.-R, Zhang, H.J., Shi, Y. and Chen, S.S. (2009) Bipolar Linear Algebra and YinYang-N-Element Cellular Networks for Equilibrium-Based Biosystem Simulation and Regulation. Journal of Biological Systems, 17, 547-576.
[77] Zhang, W.-R. (2012) YinYang Bipolar Atom—An Eastern Road toward Quantum Gravity. Journal of Modern Physics, 3, 1261-1271.
[78] Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (2006) Press Release 06-19.
[79] Huhns, M. N., Ed. (1987) Distributed Artificial Intelligence. Pitman, London.
[80] Huhns, M.N. and Singh, M.P. (1997) Readings in Agents. Morgan Kaufmann, Burlington.
[81] Huhns, M.N. (2000) An Agent-Based Global Economy. IEEE Internet Computing, 4, 83-84.
[82] Dang, J., Huang, J. and Huhns, M.N. (2007) Workflow Coordination for Service-Oriented Multiagent Systems. Proceeding of 6th International Conference on Autonomous Agents and Multiagent Systems (AAMAS-07), Honolulu, Hawaii, May 2007, 1049-1051.
[83] Zhang, W.-R. (1998) Nesting, Safety, Layering, and Autonomy: A Reorganizable Multiagent Cerebellar Architecture for Intelligent Control with Application in Legged Locomotion and Gymnastics. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part B, 28, 357-375.
[84] Zhang, W.-R. and Zhang, L. (2004) A Multiagent Data Warehousing (MADWH) and Multiagent Data Mining (MADM) Approach to Brain Modeling and Neuro-Fuzzy Control. Information Sciences, 167, 109-127.
[85] Zhang, W.-R., Chen, S. and Bezdek, J.C. (1989) POOL2: A Generic System for Cognitive Map Development and Decision Analysis. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, 19, 31-39.
[86] Zhang, W.-R., Chen, S., Wang, W. and King, R. (1992) A Cognitive Map Based Approach to the Coordination of Distributed Cooperative Agents. IEEE Transactions on SMC, 22, 103-114.
[87] Zhang, W.-R., Wang, W. and King, R. (1994) An Agent-Oriented Open System Shell for Distributed Decision Process Modeling. Journal of Organizational Computing, 4, 127-154.
[88] Zhang, W.-R. (1996) NPN Fuzzy Sets and NPN Qualitative Algebra: A Computational Framework for Bipolar Cognitive Modeling and Multiagent Decision Analysis. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, 16, 561-574.
[89] Lloyd, S. (2006) Programming the Universe. Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., New York.
[90] Salart, D., Baas, A., Branciard, C., Gisin, N. and Zbinden, H. (2008)Testing the Speed of “Spooky Action at a Distance”. Nature, 454, 861-864.
[91] Bancal, J.-D., S. Pironio, Acin, A., Liang, Y.-C., Scarani, V. and Gisin, N. (2012) Quantum Non-Locality Based on Finite-Speed Causal Influences Leads to Superluminal Signalling. Nature Physics, 8, 867-870.
[92] Yin, J., Cao, Y., Yong, H.-L., Ren, J.-G., Liang, H., Liao, S.-K., Zhou, F., Liu, C., Wu, Y.-P., Pan, G.-S., Li, L., Liu, N.-L., Zhang, Q., Peng, C.-Z. and Pan, J.-W. (2013) Bounding the Speed of “Spooky Action at a Distance”.
arXiv:1303.0614v2 [quant-ph]
[93] Penrose, R. (2005) The Road to Reality: A Complete Guide to the Laws of the Universe. Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
[94] Bennett, C.H. (1973) Logical Reversibility of Computation. IBM Journal of Research and Development, 17, 525-532.
[95] Toffoli, T. (1980) Reversible Computing. CSAIL Publications, Cambridge.
[96] Hawking, S. (2014) Information Preservation and Weather Forecasting for Black Holes. arXiv:1401.5761 [hep-th]
[97] Zhang, W.-R. (2012) Beyond Spacetime Geometry—The Death of Philosophy and Its Quantum Reincarnation. Journal of Modern Physics, 3, 1272-1284.
[98] Smolin, L. (2005) The Case for Background Independence. arXiv:hep-th/0507235v1
[99] Lukasiewicz, J. (1920) O logice trojwartosciowej. Ruch Filozoficny, 5, 170-171.
[100] Zadeh, L. (1965) Fuzzy Sets. Information and Control, 8, 338-353.
[101] Brouwer, L.E. (1912) Intuitionism and Formalism. [Dresden, A., English Trans. (1913) Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, 20, 81-96.]
[102] Belnap, N. (1977) A Useful 4-Valued Logic. In: Epstein, G. and Dunn, J.M., Eds., Modern Uses of Multiple-Valued Logic, Reidel, 8-37.
[103] Birkhoff, G. and von Neumann, J. (1936) The Logic of Quantum Mechanics. Annals of Mathematics, 37, 823-843.
[104] Hilbert, D. (1901) Mathematical Problems. Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society, 8, 437-479.
[105] Zhang, W.-R. and Peace, K.E. (2013) Revealing the Ubiquitous Effects of Quantum Entanglement—Toward a Notion of God Logic. Journal of Quantum Information Science, 3, 143-153.
[106] Godel, K. (1931) Uber formal unentscheidbare Satze der Principia Mathematica und verwandter Systeme, I. Monatshefte fur Mathematik und Physik, 38, 173-198.
[107] Rucker, R. (1987) Mind Tools—The Five Levels of Mathematical Reality. Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
[108] Engel, G.S., Calhoun, T.R., Read, E.L., Ahn, T.-K., Mancal, T., Cheng, Y.-C. and Blankenship, R.E. (2007) Evidence for Wavelike Energy Transfer through Quantum Coherence in Photosynthetic Systems. Nature, 446, 782-786.
[109] Busemeyer, J.R. and Bruza, P.D. (2012) Quantum Models of Cognition and Decision. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Copyright © 2021 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.