Perceptions of treatment among offenders with mental health problems and problematic substance use: The possible relevance of psychopathic personality traits


Substance abuse is related to re-offending, and substance abuse treatment may be effective in reducing criminal recidivism. Psychopathy, however, another factor that strongly correlates with re-offending, may be negatively associated with treatment utilization. This qualitative study explored perceptions of substance abuse treatment among offenders with mental health problems, problematic substance use, and various degrees of psychopathic personality traits. An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) revealed that some treatment perceptions may vary with degree of psychopathic traits. For instance, participants with low and high degrees of psychopathic personality traits had different views on treatment requirements imposed upon them. Many treatment perceptions were also similar between the two participant groups. Thus, treatment perceptions may not be explained by degree of psychopathic personality traits alone, but the presence of some particular psychopathic traits may be relevant in explaining certain treatment perceptions. The results highlight the complex relationship between the individual and the treatment system, and may give input to future studies on rehabilitation of offenders with multiple treatment needs.

Share and Cite:

Durbeej, N. , Alm, C. and Gumpert, C. (2014) Perceptions of treatment among offenders with mental health problems and problematic substance use: The possible relevance of psychopathic personality traits. Open Journal of Psychiatry, 4, 79-90. doi: 10.4236/ojpsych.2014.41012.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.


[1] Elbogen, E.B. and Johnson, S.C. (2009) The intricate link between violence and mental disorder: Results from the national epidemiologic survey on alcohol and related conditions. Archives of General Psychiatry, 66, 152-161.
[2] Chiles, J.A., Von Cleve, E., Jemelka, R.P. and Trupin, E.W. (1990) Substance abuse and psychiatric disorders in prison inmates. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 41, 1132-1134.
[3] Putkonen, A., Kotilainen, I., Joyal, C.C. and Tiihonen, J. (2004) Co morbid personality disorder and substance use disorders of mentally ill homicide offenders: A structured clinical study on dual and triple diagnoses. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 30, 59-72. a007068
[4] Douglas, K.S., Guy, L.S. and Hart, S.D. (2009) Psychosis as a risk factor for violence to others: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 135, 679-706.
[5] Douglas, K.S. and Skeem, J.L. (2005) Violence risk assessment. Getting specific about being dynamic. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 11, 347-383.
[6] Porter, S. and Porter, S. (2007) Psychopathy and violent crime. In: Hervé, H. and Yuille, J.C., Eds., The Psychopath: Theory, Research and Practice, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers, Mahwah, 287-300.
[7] Hare, R.D. (2003) Manual for the revised psychopathy checklist. 2nd Edition, Multi-Health Systems, Toronto.
[8] Skeem, J.L. and Cooke, D. (2010) Is criminal behavior a central component of psychopathy? Conceptual directions for resolving the debate. Psychological Assessment, 22, 433-445.
[9] Hare, R.D. and Neumann, C.S. (2010) The role of antisociality in the psychopathy construct: Comment on Skeem and Cooke. Psychological Assessment, 22, 446-454.
[10] Blackburn, R., Logan, C., Donnelly, J. and Renwick, S. (2003) Personality disorders, psychopathy and other mental disorders: Co-morbidity among patients at English and Scottish high-security hospitals. The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology, 14, 111-137. 4031000077925
[11] Hemphill, J.F., Hare, R.D. and Wong, S. (1998) Psychopathy and recidivism: A review. Legal and Criminological Psychology, 3, 139-170.
[12] Tengstrom, A., Grann, M., Langstrom, N. and Kullgren, G. (2000) Psychopathy (PCL-R) as a predictor of violent recidivism among criminal offenders with schizophrenia. Law and Human Behavior, 24, 45-58.
[13] Salekin, R.T., Worley, C. and Grimes, R.D. (2010) Treatment of psychopathy: A review and brief introduction to the mental model approach for psychopathy. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 28, 235-266.
[14] Hartwell, S.W. (2004) Triple stigma: Persons with mental illness and substance abuse problems in the criminal justice system. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 15, 84-99. 0887403403255064
[15] Lindqvist, P. (2007) Mental disorder, substance misuse and violent behavior: The Swedish experience of caring for the triply troubled. Criminal Behavior and Mental Health, 17, 242-249.
[16] Ruiz, M.A., Douglas, K.S., Edens, J.F., Nikolova, N.L. and Lilienfeld, S.O. (2012) Co occurring mental health and substance use problems in offenders: Implications for risk assessment. Psychological Assessment, 24, 77-87.
[17] Alm, C., Eriksson, A., Palmstierna, T., Kristiansson, M., Berman, A.H. and Gumpert, C.H. (2011) Treatment patterns among offenders with mental health problems and substance use problems. Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research, 38, 497-509.
[18] Gumpert, C.H., Winerdal, U., Grundtman, M., Berman, A.H., Kristiansson, M. and Palmstierna, T. (2010) The relationship between substance abuse treatment and crime relapse among individuals with suspected mental disorder, substance abuse, and antisocial behavior. Findings from the MSAC Study. International Journal of Forensic Mental Health, 9, 82-92. 9013.2010.499557
[19] Holloway, K.R., Bennet, T.H. and Farrington, D.P. (2006) The effectiveness of drug treatment programs in reducing criminal behavior: A meta-analysis. Psicothema, 18, 620-629.
[20] Mitchell, O., Wilson, D.B. and Mackenzie, D.L. (2007) Does incarceration-based drug treatment reduce recidivism? A meta-analytic synthesis of the research. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 3, 353-375.
[21] Prendergast, M.L., Podus, D., Chang, E. and Urada, D. (2002) The effectiveness of drug abuse treatment: A meta-analysis of comparison group studies. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 67, 53-72.
[22] Rice, M., Harris, G. and Cormier, C. (1992) An evaluation of a maximum security therapeutic community for psychopaths and other mentally disordered offenders. Law and Human Behavior, 16, 399-412.
[23] Young, M., Justice, J., Erdberg, P. and Gacono, C. (2000) The incarcerated psychopath in psychiatric treatment: management or treatment? In: Gacono, C., Ed., The Clinical and Forensic Assessment of Psychopathy: A Practitioner’s Guide, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers, Hillsdale, 313-331.
[24] Salekin, R.T. (2002) Psychopathy and therapeutic pessimism: Clinical lore or clinical reality? Clinical Psychology Review, 22, 79-112.
[25] Skeem, J.L., Monahan, J. and Mulvey, E.P. (2002) Psychopathy, treatment involvement, and subsequent violence among civil psychiatric patients. Law and Human Behavior, 26, 577-603.
[26] Skeem, J.L, Polaschek, D., Patrick, C.J. and Lilienfeld, S.O. (2011) Psychopathic personality: Bridging the gap between scientific evidence and public policy. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 12, 95-162.
[27] Taylor, J. and Lang, A.R. (2006) Psychopathy and substance use disorders. In: Patrick, C.J., Ed., Handbook of Psychopathy, Guilford Press, New York, 495-511.
[28] Alterman, A.I., Rutherford, M., Cacciola, J.S., McKay, J. and Boardman, C. (1998) Prediction of 7 months methadone maintenance treatment response by four measures of antisociality. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 49, 217-223.
[29] Richards, H.J., Casey, J.O. and Lucente, S.W. (2003) Psychopathy and treatment response in incarcerated female substance abusers. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 30, 251-276.
[30] Tsogia, D., Copello, A. and Orford, J. (2001) Entering treatment for substance misuse: A review of the literature. Journal of Mental Health, 10, 481-499.
[31] Thornton, D. and Blud, L. (2007) The influence of psychopathic traits on response to treatment. In: Hervé, H. and Yuille, J.C., Eds., The Psychopath: Theory, Research and Practice, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers, Mahwah, 411-428.
[32] Maxwell, J.A. (2005) Qualitative research design. An interactive approach. 2nd Edition, Sage, Thousand Oakes.
[33] Durbeej, N., Berman, A.H., Gumpert, C.H., Palmstierna, T., Kristiansson, M. and Alm, C. (2010) Validation of the alcohol use disorders identification test and the drug use disorders identification test in a Swedish sample of suspected offenders with signs of mental health problems: Results from the mental disorder, substance abuse and crime study. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 39, 364-377.
[34] Saunders, J.B., Aasland, O.G., Babor, T.F., de la Fuente, J.R. and Grant, B.F. (1993) Development of the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT): WHO collaborative project on early detection of persons with harmful alcohol consumption. Addiction, 88, 791-804.
[35] Berman, A.H., Bergman, H., Palmstierna, T. and Schlyter, F. (2005) Evaluation of the Drug Use Disorders Identification Test (DUDIT) in criminal justice and detoxifications settings and in Swedish population sample. European Addiction Research, 11, 22-31.
[36] The National Board of Health and Welfare (2007) Nationella riktlinjer for missbruksoch beroendevard: Vagledning for socialtjanstens och halsooch sjukvardens verksamhet for personer med missbruksoch beroendeproblem [Swedish national guidelines for treatment of substance abuse and dependence]. The National Board of Health and Welfare, Stockholm.
[37] Grann, M., Langstrom, N., Tengstrom, A. and Stalenheim, E.G. (1998) Reliability of file based retrospective ratings of psychopathy with the PCL-R. Journal of Personality Assessment, 70, 416-426.
[38] Hare, R.D. (1991) The Hare PCL-R: Rating booklet. Multi-Health Systems, Toronto.
[39] Fulero, S. (1995) Review of the hare psychopathy checklist-revised. In: Conoley, J.C. and Impara, J.C., Eds., Twelfth Mental Measurements Yearbook, Buros Institute, Lincoln, 453-454.
[40] Smith, J.A., Jarman, M. and Osborn, M. (1999) Doing interpretative phenomenological analysis. In: Murray, M. and Chamberlain, K., Eds., Qualitative Health Psychology: Theories and Methods, Sage, London, 218-241.
[41] Cacciola, J.S., Alterman, A.I., Habing, B. and McLellan, A.T. (2011) Recent status score for version 6 of the Addiction Severity Index (ASI-6). Addiction, 106, 1588-1602.
[42] ?berg, D., Sallmén, B., Berman, A.H. and Horner, C. (2006) Swedish version of the ASI-6. Adapted version, MSAC-project. Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm.
[43] Kessler, F., Cacciola, J.S., Alterman, A.I., Faller, S., Souza-Formigioni, M.L., Santos Cruz, M., et al. (2012) Psychometric properties of the sixth version of the Addiction Severity Index (ASI-6) in Brazil. Revsita Brasiliera de Psiquiatria, 34, 24-33.
[44] Smith, J.A., Flowers, P. and Larkin, M. (2009) Interpretative phenomenological analysis: Theory, method and research. Sage, London.
[45] Crabtree, B.F. and Miller, W.L. (1999) Doing qualitative research. Sage, Thousand Oakes.
[46] Martin, D.J., Garske, J.P. and Davis, M.K. (2000) Relation of the therapeutic alliance with outcome and other variables: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 68, 438-450.
[47] Kettunen, T., Poskiparta, M. and Gerlander, M. (2002) Nurse-patient power relationship: Preliminary evidence of patients’ power messages. Patient Education and Counseling, 47, 101-113.
[48] Blomqvist, J., Palm, J. and Storbjork, J. (2009) “More cure and less control” or “more care and lower costs”? Recent changes in services for problem drug users in Stockholm and Sweden. Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy, 16, 479-496.
[49] Brunette, M., Mueser, K.T. and Drake, R.E. (2004) A review of research on residential programs for people with severe mental illness and co-occurring substance use disorders. Drug and Alcohol Review, 23, 471-481.
[50] Bobrova, N., Rhodes, T., Power, R., Alcorn, R., Neifeld, E., Krasiukov, N., et al. (2006) Barriers to accessing drug treatment in Russia: A qualitative study among injecting drug users in two cities. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 82, 57-63.
[51] Mowbray, O., Perron, B.E., Bohnert, A.S., Krentzman, A.R. and Vaughn, M.G. (2010) Service use and barriers to care among heroin users: Results from a national survey. The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 36, 305-310.
[52] Cunningham, J.A., Sobell, L.C., Sobell, M.B. and Gaskinn, J. (1994) Alcohol and drug abusers’ reasons for seeking treatment. Addictive Behaviors, 19, 691-698. 90023-X
[53] Orford, J., Kerr, C., Copello, A., Hodgson, R., Alwyn, T., Black, R., Smith, M., Thistlethwaite, G., Westwood, A. and Slegg, G. (2006) Why people enter treatment for alcohol problems: Findings from UK alcohol treatment trial pre-treatment interviews. Journal of Substance Use, 11, 161-176.
[54] Morse, J.M. (1999) Qualitative generalizability. Qualitative Health Research, 9, 5-6.

Copyright © 2023 by authors and Scientific Research Publishing Inc.

Creative Commons License

This work and the related PDF file are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.