The Genesis and Paradigm Shift in Forest Inventory: Bangladesh Chapter ()
1. Introduction
Ancient populations were highly dependent on the forest for food and shelter. The utilization, and destruction of forest resources, have increased significantly with the progress of human civilization (Williams, 2003; FAO, 2016). Large-scale conversion of forests to agricultural lands was observed in the middle age to meet the demand for food for the increasing population. The forests were converted for other land uses (e.g., urban areas, industrial estates, sea, airports, etc.) (Lambin & Meyfroidt, 2011; FAO, 2016). The 1st, 2nd, and 3rd industrial revolutions also accelerated these conversions (Lambin & Meyfroidt, 2011) and led to the establishment of many governments and privately-owned wood-based industries in Bangladesh in the last century (Banglapedia, 2021a). At present, large-scale wood-based industries, e.g., furniture, pulp, paper, etc., are also operating around the globe to fulfill the demand of society (Hetemäki & Hurmekoski, 2016; Ramage et al., 2017). With time, people realize the importance of forests for national and household demand, livelihood, and environmental well-being (Turner et al., 2006). Assessment of forest resources is essential to ascertain the present and future uses (FAO, 2015). On the other hand, the conversion, protection, and conservation initiatives for the forests of Indo-Bangladesh have changed with time (Millat-e-Mustafa, 2002). Knowledge of the importance of forests at the local, regional and global scale and the utilization of forest resources help to formulate forest policy, conservation, and utilization strategies. Therefore, the existing forest policy, the demand of society and nation, available knowledge and technologies, and contemporary national and global issues ultimately govern the extent and objectives of forest inventory (FAO, 2020). Forest inventory is the footing of forest management. Bangladesh (Indo-Bangladesh region) has a long history of scientific forest management that started in 1869 with the appointment of an Assistant Conservator of forest for the region (Bhattacharyya, 2011; Adrija, 2017). However, good numbers of forest inventories have been reported for the Indo-Bangladesh since 1764. The initial inventories delineated the forest boundary and the latter assessed the biomass and carbon stocking in a forest ecosystem, land use, and community dependency on the forest using a field survey of high-resolution satellite image (Costello et al., 2016).
This study reviewed all the available inventories of Indo-Bangladesh to independent Bangladesh based on objectives, use of technologies, outputs and tried to align with the motive of the rulers, existing forest policy and contemporary national and global issues. This study will give an insight into each inventory that can help to classify them into the distinct time frame and help to understand the drivers and their role in changing the outputs of inventories with time. It organizes the findings of the evaluation of forest inventory into four distinct periods and ends with a conclusion.
2. Forest Inventories in Bangladesh
A total of 30 forest inventories have been identified for the Indo-Bangladesh region since 1764. Among these inventories, six inventories/surveys were conducted during the British colonial period. Only 3 inventories were conducted by the Pakistan regime, while 21 inventories were led after the independence of Bangladesh including two national forest inventories (Annex 1). The forests of Bangladesh can be classified into five zones as Sundarbans, Hill, Sal, Coastal and Village (GoB, 2019) and all the inventories were categorized according to the forest zones for further discussion. Early inventories (1764 to 1960) were vested only for the Sundarbans, but the highest number of inventories were conducted for the Hill zone followed by the Sundarbans (Figure 1) (Annex 1). All the inventories used the field survey method and only 7 included both the field survey and remote sensing techniques for the production forest maps (Figure 2). A wide array of output was observed for these inventories and the outputs were organized into 15 distinct categories starting from forest boundary demarcation to biodiversity, biomass and carbon stock, and social and economic considerations. However, growing stock assessment in terms of volume was the highest parameter of interest followed by the production of maps (Figure 3). The objectives/outputs of
Figure 1. Number of forest inventories (2 National Forest inventories are excluded) for forest zones of Bangladesh since 1764 (Annex).
Figure 2. Data collection methods for forest inventories in Bangladesh since 1764 (Annex).
Figure 3. Major outputs of forest inventories in Bangladesh since 1764 (Annex).
inventories were found to vary in time, availabilities of technologies, resources utilization, quality and quantity of forest resources, forest policy and needs of the society and country (Kohl et al., 2006).
3. Evolution of the Forest Inventory
The number of inventories for the particular forest zone, the method of data/information collection, and the outputs of each inventory varied significantly (Costello et al., 2016). Bangladesh (Indo-Bangladesh to independent Bangladesh) has more than two hundred fifty years of history in forest inventory starting from 1764, which can be divided into four distinct periods (Mid eighteenth to the late nineteenth century: 1764-1876; Early Twentieth century: 1905-1924; Mid-twenty to the late twentieth century: 1958-2000; and Early twenty-first century: 2001-present) based on outputs and technology used. The number of inventories has increased significantly and also the outputs of inventories were getting complex and diversified with time and technology of data/information collection (Figure 4). The comparatively highest rate (3.81 inventory/10 years) was observed for the early twenty-first century (2001-present) and the lowest (0.04 inventory/10 years) was observed from the mid-eighteenth to the late nineteenth century (1764-1876) (Figure 5). However, we are interested in finding the linkage between the objectives/outputs of these forest inventories and the intention of rulers/administrators, available technologies, existing forest policy, and contemporary national and global issues.
3.1. Mid Eighteenth to Late Nineteenth Century (1764-1876)
The mid-eighteenth to the late nineteenth century (1764-1876) was the British
Figure 4. Time period of forest inventories along their outputs, forest zones and data/information collection procedure (Annex).
Figure 5. Rate (number of inventory/10 years) of forest inventory in each period (Annex).
colonial regime in India. The forest inventories during this period were only vested for the Sundarbans. The British East India Company took absolute control over the Indo-Bangladesh after the battle of Plassey in West Bangle and Buxar in Bihar in 1757 and 1764 respectively. As new administrators, they developed maps to demarcate the boundary of important places and areas of interest, which enabled them to ensure their strategic, administrative, and economic activities over the territory (Adrija, 2017). As part of these activities, the British administrator took the first initiative to demarcate the boundary of the Sundarbans in 1764. They also prepared a map of the larger waterways of the Sundarbans from 1767 to 1773. Eventually, it was the part of The Bangal Atlas that was published in 1779 by James Rennel (Bhattacharyya, 2011; Banglapedia, 2021b).
The trigonometric methods of the survey gained popularity and accuracy over the previous technology of cartographic at the beginning of the nineteenth century (1802) in India (Gill, 2001). From 1821 to 1829, Lt. Princep, and Lt. Hodges used trigonometric method of the survey to delineate the accurate boundary between the Sundarbans and cultivated lands and they produced a map (scale: 1 inch = 1 mile) for the Sundarbans. Again, Mr. James Ellison 1851 to 1859, produced another map of the Sundarbans at a smaller scale of 1 inch = 4 miles. He also conducted a revenue survey for the Sundarbans for the first time in the history of the forest inventory of Indo-Bangladesh (Annex 1) (Costello et al., 2016). Delineation of forest boundaries and prepared forest maps were used to convert a part of the Sundarbans to cultivable lands and a significant forest area was converted to agricultural lands within 1875 (Bhattacharyya, 2011). However, this conversion was not profitable due to the unfavorable environmental conditions and less productive capacity of the soil (Mahmood et al., 2021).
After 1865, a significant improvement was noted with the declaration of the Indian Forest Act 1865. The appointment of an Assistant Conservator of Forests in 1869 was the first step of Forest Administration in Indo-Bangladesh, which was the starting of scientific forest management in Indo-Bangladesh. Moreover, the first forest policy was declared in 1894 with the objective of revenue generation from the forests and giving importance to advancing the agriculture sectors (Millat-e-Mustafa, 2002).
3.2. Early Twentieth Century (1905-1924)
The forest policy of 1894 likely influenced the revenue generation from the forest through production forestry as well as continued to convert forest areas to agricultural lands (Bhattacharyya, 2011; Mahmood et al., 2021). It can be believed that the objectives/outputs (e.g., demarcation of forest areas, preparation of forest maps, and stock assessment) of the subsequent inventories were to detect the change dynamics over time. Dhaka, Chittagong, and Sundarbans forest divisions were established at almost the same time. But, the Sundarbans got the attention of the forest inventory during this period. The fifth forest inventory was conducted from 1905 to 1909 to produce maps (scale: 1 inch = 1 mile) to assess the changes in forest land cover after the conversion to agricultural lands. In 1924, Mr. Curtis produced the largest map of the Sundarbans with a scale of 2 inches = 1 mile and assessed the growing stock (volume) of the important tree species of the Sundarbans and assessed the gain and loss of forest land areas due to accretion and erosion over the time (Annex 1). The inventory by Curtis was complex compared to the previous and he used statistical calculation for the first time. Until that time, extraction of forest resources and revenue earning were the central concerns of forest management (Mahmood et al., 2021).
A comprehensive new Forest Act was adopted in 1927. The administrative capacity of the forest personnel was enhanced significantly for the management of the forests (Rahman, 2005). On the other hand, the forest policy 1894 was revised in 1955 to address the contemporary issues after the independence of Pakistan, and a new forest policy was declared in 1955. This policy was significantly updated with the view of the utilization of forest resources for the national demand as well as conservation of forests and protection of wildlife (Millat-e-Mustafa, 2002; Biswas & Choudhury, 2007). The policy statements influenced the outputs of the subsequent inventories for the period from 1958 - to 1984 (Annex 1).
3.3. Mid-Twentieth to Late Twentieth Century (1958-2000)
A total of 15 forest inventories were conducted during this period. Among them, three were during the Pakistan regime, and the rest of the twelve were after the independence of Bangladesh, which covered the Sundarbans, Hill, Village and Coastal zone (Annex 1). This period experienced the implementation of four forest policies, e.g., Forest policy 1955, Forest policy 1962, Forest policy 1979 and Forest policy 1994. The forest policy 1955 and 1962 emphasized the commercial utilization of forest resources as production forestry, development of forest base industries, improvement of forest stock through natural regeneration and plantation. It is believed that these policy statements had a significant influence on the utilization and management of forest resources and the formulation of objectives of the concerned forest inventory. It could be the reason for experiencing different categories of forest inventories in terms of the use of technologies, parameters of interest, extent, inclusion of forest types/zones, and outputs. However, the inventory outputs increased significantly compared to the early twentieth century (1904-1924).
Remote sensing (aerial photo) technology was used in 1958 for the first time in the forest inventory with the field survey (Annex 1). It was the evolution in the preparation of more accurate forest maps on a larger scale. FORESTAL (Forestry and Engineering International Limited, Canada) conducted forest inventories for the Sundarbans, Sangu-Matamuhuri reserved forests, Kassalong and Rankhiang reserve forests during 1958-59, 1961-63 and 1964, respectively. The objectives of these inventories were to prepare forest maps, assessment of growing stock (volume), and supply of raw materials for the forest-based industries, e.g., Karnaphuli Paper Mill Ltd., Khulna Newsprint Mill Ltd., Khulna Hard Board Mill Ltd., and Karnaphuli Rayon & Chemical Ltd. those were established in-between 1953 to 1967.
The first forest policy was approved in 1979 after the independence of Bangladesh, which continued until 1994. The Forest Policy 1979 focused on the scientific management of forests, development and raw material support to forest-based industries, discouraging the conversion of forest areas to other uses, enhancement of plantation activities in coastal areas and depleted hills, ensuring the mass participation in plantation (Millat-e-Mustafa, 2002). The first inventory of village forest (village zone) was conducted in 1980-81 to estimate the wood and non-wood stocking. From 1981 to 1984, a total of four inventories was conducted for hill zone (Kaptai reserved forest; Sangu and Matamuhuri Reserve Forests, Kassalong and Rankhiang reserves; Sitapahar reserved forest and Chittagong and Cox’s Bazar Forest Divisions) to assess the growing stock (volume), delineation of forest type and preparation of maps using field survey and aerial photos. On the other hand, Overseas Development Administration (ODA) in 1980 conducted a comprehensive inventory of the Sundarbans. It was the first generation of modern inventory comprising seven outputs (Annex 1). Till today, this inventory is considered a basis of comparison for the vegetation types of the Sundarbans and growing stock (volume) (Mahmood et al., 2021). Piloting of coastal plantation was mentioned in Forest Policy 1962, while Forest Policy 1979 gave further importance to the implementation of coastal plantation on the coasts and offshore islands. In 1987, the first inventory was conducted on the coastal afforestation with mangrove species. In this inventory, Bangladesh Space Research and Remote Sensing Organization (SPARRSO) produced land accretion and plantation maps. They also assessed the growing stock (volume) and growth of the coastal plantation (Drigo et al., 1987). Here the linkage between the Forest Policies and inventories inventory was identical. At the same time, Bangladesh Forest Department with SPARRSO conducted another inventory for the Southern Sylhet Forest Division and assessed the growing stock (volume) and produced maps for vegetation and forest area (Drigo et al., 1988).
At the end of this period, a new forest policy evolved in 1994. This policy highlighted the mass scale afforestation on both public and private lands; conservation and protection of biodiversity and natural habitats; implementation of various efforts and government ratified agreements relating to global warming, desertification; encroachment, illegal felling of trees and hunting of wild animals; and effective utilization of forest products/resources. This policy opened a new horizon of forest management in Bangladesh, which is reflected in all aspects of subsequent forest inventories for the different forest zones. On the other hand, National Environmental Management Action Plan was developed for the period of 1995 to 2005 to address the actions required to reduce the rate of environmental degradation, improvement of the natural environment, conservation of habitats and biodiversity, which were very much related to the forestry sector (GoB, 1995). In 1998, Bangladesh Forest Department also conducted several inventories to develop Forest Resource Management Plan (FRMP) for different forest divisions. These inventories derived growing sock (volume), stand projection, forest area map, listing of the major species and regeneration status (Annex 1). Thus, these inventories addressed the focal statements of the Forest Policy 1994 and National Environmental Management Action Plan 1995.
3.4. Early Twenty First Century (2001-Present)
At the beginning of the twenty-first century, the Sal zone of Bangladesh (Sal Forests of Dhaka, Tangail, Mymensingh, Dinajpur, Rangpur, and Rajshahi forest divisions) was bought under inventory for the first time to assess the growing stock (volume), forest structure, list of the major species, and regeneration status. Two nationwide inventories were conducted in 2005-2007 and 2017 to assess the forest cover, land classes and other parameters. These nationwide inventories were vast and comprehensive in nature (Annex 1). However, the nationwide forest inventory of 2017 used the latest modern equipment and data/information collection methods with a higher degree of accuracy compared to all inventories in the past (Hossain et al., 2019). A special inventory on the floral diversity of the Sundarbans was also conducted in 2014. Besides these, there were four inventories in different protected areas of the Hill and Coastal zones of Bangladesh (Annex 1).
The nationwide forest inventory of 2005-2007 assessed the biomass and carbon stock in the forested and trees outside the forest with other parameters of interest for the first time in the history of forest inventory (Annex 1). Climate change issues and their mitigation measures and the role of forests are well-discussed agendas around the globe and in Bangladesh at the beginning of this century. Along with these, The Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) under the Kyoto Protocol, Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) (Goal 7 Ensure environmental sustainability), Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) (Goal 13 Climate action: Take urgent action to combat climate change and its impact), Bangladesh Climate Change Strategic Action Plan 2009, UU-REDD Bangladesh Programme and The Bangladesh National REDD+ Strategy (BNRS) or action plan have significant contributions in formulating the objectives/outputs of the forest inventories in the early twenty-first century. It could be the reason for estimating the biomass and carbon stock in the forested and protected areas by most of the inventories (7 out of 9) in this period (Annex 1). These measurements and outputs of the recent forest inventories have made them compatible with the national and global interest in climate change mitigation measures.
4. Conclusion
The forest inventories in Bangladesh were started before starting forest management initiatives during the Indo-Bangladesh regime. With time, the objectives and outputs of forest inventories were aligned with the demand of society, administrators of the country, and forest policies. It is evidenced that the forest inventories of Bangladesh have addressed the national and global climate change perspectives, which is the prime concern at this time. It is believed that the present form and extent of forest inventories in Bangladesh will be able to support sustainable forest management and sustainable development of the country.
Acknowledgements
The author acknowledges the cordial support of the Bangladesh Forest Department for providing access and collection of information from their achieve.
Annex
Annex 1. List of forest inventory for the Bangladesh and the related information (Source: Costello et al., 2016).