1. Introduction
Self-medication with drugs or alternative medicines is a common form of care that calls upon public health actors [1]. The World Health Organization (WHO) has indicated that self-medication can be acceptable, when properly taught and controlled until it fully integrates into society behavior. However, it can be a threat to public health if it is not supervised [2].
In Africa, several studies have presented prevalence of self-medication. Among students residing at the Kasapa Campus of the University of Lubumbashi, A prevalence of 99% has been found [3]. In Ghana, a study that looked specifically at self-medication with antibiotics found a prevalence of 70% [4].
In Senegal, this practice is also very common and has been the subject of several studies [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] which revealed very alarming prevalence. We can take as examples. A study entitled “Self-treatment of fever in the Dakar district” revealed a prevalence of 81% [5]. Another study carried out in Grand-Yoff had shown that 80% of those surveyed practiced self-medication [10].
Although self-care does not constitute recent behavior and has been the subject of several works, current practices as the representations which underlie them have new characteristics, in connection with the technology revolution information and communication (ICT). A significant number of individuals choose a therapeutic product by engaging with their group, whose experience they harness. Up to global knowledge accessible by internet [11], this is what explains the success of medical websites, which are not lacking in sociability, and is expressed particularly in forums which host exchanges of very personal experiences putting people in touch with communities of virtual patients [11]. However, this aspect of self-medication remains poorly documented, hence the purpose of this work to determine its extent.
2. Methodology
2.1. Study Framework
Senegal is situated in the western-most part of the African continent on the Atlantic Ocean where Europe. Africa and the Americas converge and at the crossroads of major air and shipping routes.
According to the Senegalese population projection report 2013-2063 [12], the population of Senegal is estimated in 2019 at 16,209,125 inhabitants, 50.2% of whom are women.
Senegal has a satisfactory level of telephone and internet coverage, and the low literacy rate (57.9%) is not a constraint to the mobile penetration rate estimated at 103.2% in March 2017. The mobile telephony market is still dominated by prepaid offers (99.4% of the total population). The penetration rate of internet services was 57.6% in June 2017 with 8,965,507 internet subscribers [13].
Analysis of the digital sector indicates that telecommunications infrastructure remains among the most developed and efficient in West Africa thanks to significant investments made in terms of capacity and modernization. Indeed. on the infrastructure sub-index. the “Network Readiness Index” (NRI) from World Economic Forum 2016 placed Senegal in the leading group in West Africa with Nigeria. Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana and in the 14th place in Africa [13].
Compared to media and the internet in particular, the 2017 Demographic and Health Survey [14] found that 29% of women and 43% of men reported using the internet in the past 12 months.
2.2. Study Type
This is a cross-sectional survey with descriptive aims on knowledge. attitudes and practices in terms of self-medication on the Facebook network among Senegalese women which took place from June 10 to 30. 2019.
2.3. Study Population and Sampling Protocol
The study population was represented by all of the women registered in one or more of the following four Facebook groups:
· “Femme chic”: created on June 12. 2016. with 145.000 members;
· “Ladies club”: created on April 16. 2016. with 56.300 members;
· “Femme leader”: created on April 6. 2015. with 43.700 members;
· “Entre yaays”: created on March 25. 2013 with 11.700 members.
To be included in this study, the woman had to declare to be of Senegalese nationality and to be registered on one of the targeted Facebook groups. Since participation in the study was done on a voluntary basis, the only criterion for non-inclusion online was that the questionnaire was not completed.
The sample size was calculated by the Schwartz formula
.
With prevalence of self-medication in women by Facebook’s groups not known, we chose 50%, ε = 1.96 and an accuracy of 5%, the number is equal to 385 individuals.
No survey was conducted, all members wishing to participate in the study during the collection period were included.
2.4. Collection of Data
A questionnaire following the specific objectives of the study and drawing inspiration from studies on the same theme. It included 45 questions divided into three sections:
· Socio-professional data: age, marital status, number of children, schooling, type of schooling, level of schooling, current school situation, income-generating activity, status of nursing staff, etc.
· Use of social networks: number of social networks subscribed, date of subscription on Facebook, number of friends on Facebook, frequency of connection on Facebook, number of groups of women on Facebook, etc.
· Knowledge and practices of self-medication: knowledge of self-medication, practice of self-medication, health problems causing self-medication, search for medical information through social network.
The questionnaire was scanned in XLSform format with the application Open Data Kit (ODK). After validation of the format, its online deployment was made thanks to the Ona.IO platform.
From the Ona.IO platform, a link was generated and then posted on the wall of the different Facebook groups targeted by the study. Information of these groups was therefore posted on their walls and an information form posted which made it possible to share the objectives and the ethical considerations of the study. At the bottom of this form was the link to the questionnaire.
This link enabled the various consenting members to fill out the online questionnaire directly, without the possibility of participating repeatedly through the same IP address.
The questionnaire was therefore self-administered over a three-week period from June 10 to 30. 2019, time to reach the sample size.
2.5. Data Analysis
At the end of the data collection, a database in csv format was generated from the online platform. This database was cleaned and then analyzed with the R software.
The description of the qualitative variables was done through frequency measurements, that of the quantitative variables called for the calculation of arithmetic means with their standard deviation.
2.6. Ethical Considerations
The consent of the people surveyed was previously obtained through the information form. Consent was given by the opening of the questionnaire and its filling which was done remotely on a voluntary basis.
Respondents were informed of the objectives and constraints of the study, of their rights to refuse to participate in the study or to leave it at any time. Anonymity and confidentiality were respected.
3. Results
After three weeks of posting the questionnaire, 508 women were surveyed in the targeted Facebook groups.
The women surveyed were on average 30.7 years old, with a standard deviation of 8.7 years. The extreme ages were 58 and 15, with a predominance of women 40 to 45 (Figure 1).
Study participants subscribed on average to 3 social networks, with a standard deviation of 1.2 social networks. After Facebook. the women surveyed mainly subscribed to WhatsApp and Twitter (Figure 2).
The women surveyed were educated (98.8%), married (45.5%) and had an income-generating activity (54.1%). They lived in the Dakar region (49.8%) and had been active on Facebook for five years and more in 49.8% (Table 1).
The women interviewed addressed health issues in the Facebook groups of which they were a member in 62.2% of the cases. The sources of information used by women in the event of a health problem were mainly health professionals (77%), the Internet (59%) and social networks (18%) including Facebook
Figure 1. Distribution of women surveyed by age group (n = 508).
Figure 2. Distribution of women surveyed according to social networks subscribed (n = 508).
Table 1. Characteristics of women (n = 508).
(15%) (Figure 3).
Self-medication was practiced by 68.9% of the women surveyed. Headache and dysmenorrhea (painful menstruation) were the most treated problems by self-medication among the women surveyed (Table 2).
Among the respondents 311 had once seen on a wall, or received medical information through Facebook, a proportion of 61.2%. In this proportion, 41.8%, or 130 were related to drug prescriptions. The other advice related to hygienic dietetics (96.1%), a consultation with a qualified health professional (54.6%), a consultation with a healer (50.4%).
Figure 3. Distribution of women surveyed by medical information sources (n = 508).
Table 2. Health problems managed by self-medication (n = 350).
A proportion of 16% of women receiving advice on taking medication through Facebook systematically checked them with a health professional. The most commonly used drugs were simple painkillers (paracetamol) and vitamins. However, other very sensitive products were also recommended through Facebook such as central action painkillers (20.0%), antibiotics (40.0%), antihypertensive drugs (5.4%) and antidiabetics (6.9%) (Table 3).
The oral tablet (92.3%) and syrup (50.0%) were the most common dosage forms found in self-medication on Facebook. Injectables and eye drops were found in 5.4% of cases, however (Table 3).
Among women who received medication advice through Facebook, 60%, or 78, had used it. The drugs were mainly purchased from pharmacies (72.4%). No woman reported buying it on the street (Table 4).
The use of Facebook groups to self-medicate would be advantageous compared to medical consultations because of its accessibility, time savings and the
Table 3. Drugs recommended on Facebook groups used (n = 130).
Table 4. Medication recommended on the Facebook groups used (n = 78).
effectiveness of the advice provided (Table 4).
4. Discussion
This study focused on Senegalese women subscribing to female Facebook groups (Femme chic, Ladies club, Entre Yaays, or Femme leaders). The main limitation of this study is the fact that the data collected was exclusively declarative. No verification could be made. However, this approach gives an advantage because it makes the respondent more comfortable. The ethical considerations on anonymity and data security being shared in the information form, and the absence of collection of personal data was an advantage because the woman was alone and free to give all the answers, thus avoiding bias courtesy.
In our study, the average age of the participants is 30.7 years. This can be justified by the chosen study framework, the Facebook social network, used mainly by young internet users. The results of a Senmarkting study converge with this, revealing that in Senegal, users between 16 and 25 years of age dominate social networks like Facebook and Instagram [15]. The women who participated in our study were educated in 98.8% of cases. And 97.6% of them had gone to French school to a higher level (73%). These results are also justified by the study framework which is more used by educated people. And they agree with those from the 2017 DHS showing that internet use increases with educational level, passing among women from 7% among those with no education to 63% among those with intermediate / secondary level or more [14].
The study reveals that among the 508 women surveyed 350 self-medication, a prevalence of 68.9%. This prevalence is below those found by other studies carried out in Senegal. Thiam T [9] found an 80% prevalence in Grand Yoff ; Samb ES had objectified during a survey in the Kaolack region a prevalence of 83% [16]. In the African region higher prevalence have been found. Chiribagula VB [3] had found in students aged 18 to 35 living on the Kasapa campus of the University of Lubumbashi a prevalence of 99%, Kitengye LJ [17], meanwhile ended up with 57.4 % self-medication in the elderly. However, none of these studies evaluated self-medication specifically through social networks, it was evaluated across all communication channels.
The main health problems that lead women to self-medicate in general were mainly headaches, painful periods and stomach aches. This is due to the frequency of these symptoms in women and their impression of "not serious". According to Hariri J [18] the indications for self-medication are mainly asthenia, fever, digestive and intestinal pain, rhinitis, and minor dermatological conditions. He justifies this by a clear view of the signs but also the obtaining of drugs without medical prescription. According to Chiribagula VB [3] malaria (82.4%), fever (65.5%), headache (65.5%), cough (62%) as well as bacterial infections (50.6%) are the top five causes of self-medication. Samb ES [16] highlighted three self-medicating symptoms, namely headache (91%), fever (68%), cough (65%), and diarrhea (64%).
Regarding the most used drugs we found painkillers with simple action (84.6%), vitamins (66.9%), appetite stimulants (45.4%) and antibiotics (40%). This could be due on the one hand to the over-the-counter sale of these drugs (without prescription) but also to a cost less (Bamako Initiative), but above all the fact that these drugs are very well known to the general public. Queneau [19] found overlapping results with as main self-prescriptions aspirin and other analgesics (30.6%), ointments (8.9%), hypnotics and tranquilizers (8.6%), laxatives (6.1%), gastric dressings (3.7%) and tonics (2.7%).
The dosage forms of the drugs used were mainly oral tablets (92.3%), syrup / concentrate (50%), ointments (43.1%) dermal creams (34.6%), and ova gynecological (17.7%), Chiribagula VB found that the tablet (37%) was the most used form of self-medication [17].
The reasons cited as leading to self-medication on Facebook or the internet are, the accessibility of Facebook (67.8%), the saving of time (33.9%), and money (18.6%) on consultation, reliability of medical information previously received (28.8%). Samb ES [16] had already mentioned the lack of money, the lack of time, the perfect knowledge of drugs and their use, the prescription to be renewed as factors influencing the practice of self-medication.
5. Conclusions
The image of self-medication has changed depending on both the changes in the health system and the evolution of the status of the patient considered today as an autonomous subject. This phenomenon occurs in the digital age, where medical information is made available to everyone on the internet and social networks.
This study has shown that self-medication through social networks is a reality among Senegalese women and can serve as a platform for prescribing traditional unlicensed drugs. This situation calls on all health actors because unsupervised self-medication can cause major individual and public health problems. Reinforcement of communication for health, through these networks should be operated to prevent the health risks that this practice could cause.