Fossil Stomatocysts in Upper Cretaceous Sedimentary Pyrite from Central Mexico ()
Stomatocyst are structures representing a siliceous resting stage produced by Heterokontophyte algae of the classes Chrysophyceae (“golden brown algae”) and Synurophyceae [14] commonly referred as Chrysophycean algae or simply “Chrysophytes” [15]. They expose a great variety of morphologies consisting of spherical, oval or even pyramidal forms with a single pore [15,16]. Globose forms expose a diameter, which ranges from approximately 2 - 4 mm to 30 mm [15,16]. Surface of stomatocysts also shows presence or absence of ornamentation, and when it is present, it has a wide variation of patterns and structures [17]. So far, more than 400 different morphotypes have been described [14] from several localities in the world; however, in most specimens an accurate taxonomical identification is still necessary [15,16]. Commonly, the stomatocysts accumulate in lacustrine sediments [14,15,18], however some specimens have been described in brackish waters from mangrove habitats of the Caribbean Sea [19] and Central Poland [20]. Reports of stomatocysts in the marine realm are very rare; they are known from sediments of the Caribbean Sea [21], the Southwest Pacific (late Cretaceous, late Eocene and Neogene) [22], the Weddel Sea, Antartica (early Cretaceous: Albian) [23], the Norwegian Sea (Eocene to Pliocene) [24] and the western south Atlantic (Tertiary) [19,20,25]. Some fossils stomatocysts have been reported as minor components in sediments of the Gulf of Mexico, however they were described as freshwater elements [26].
Concerning pyritized forms, a series of pyritized spheres identified as cysts of the genus Tasmanites, a Prasinophycean algae has been reported from the Upper Devonian Chatanooga Shale, at the states of Tennessee and Kentucky, and from other Devonian localities within the state of New York, Unites States of America [13]. This report could represent the only record of pyritized cysts in Devonian sediments in the world. In Mexico, stomatocysts are reported from lacustrine sediments [27] as well as in marine sediments from the Gulf of Mexico area [20]. And so far, no stomatocysts have been reported from sedimentary pyrite in neither lacustrine nor brackish deposits in Mexico; however, a preliminary work [28] reported an unidentified sphere, which is recognized as stomatocyst in this document.
In this paper six biomorphic structures assigned as stomatocysts based on their morphology, size and presence or absence of ornamentation are described. The material here studied was collected from sedimentary pyrite hosted in Upper Cretaceous limestone of the Agua Nueva Formation at the locality of Xilitla, state of San Luis Potosí, Central Mexico (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Localization map of Xilitla, state of San Luis Potosí, Central Mexico.
2. Geological Setting
Stomatocysts described in this paper have been collected from sedimentary pyrite disposed as millimetric lamina and 2cm-thick lenses within well-laminated limestone of the Upper Cretaceous Agua Nueva Formation at Xilitla, San Luis Potosí, Mexico. At the study area, this lithostratigraphic unit consists of decimetric limestone alternating with occasional beds of brown shale and green bentonite [11,29-31] (Figure 2). At some levels, limestone exposes parallel lamination at millimetric scale, and bears centimetric layers of black chert as well as millimetric laminae and centimetric lenses of sedimentary pyrite [10,30,32].
This unit is widely distributed in Mexico, and was deposited from the Burgos Basin in northeastern Mexico, through the Tampico-Misantla basin to southern Mexico-
Figure 2. The Agua Nueva Formation at Xilitla, Central Mexico. (A) Outcrop, (B) Layer of sedimentary pyrite.
during the latest part of the Cenomanian throughout the Turonian [33] (Figure 3). At the locality of Xilitla and its vicinity, this unit has a thickness of approximately 100 m [34]. According to lithological evidences published by previous works [30,32,35], a deficient concentration of oxygen prevailed at the water sediment interface during the deposition of the laminated-pyrite-bearing limestone of the Agua Nueva Formation, under low energy condi-
Figure 3. Paleogeographic map of the Late Cenomanian throughout the Turonian, modified from [33].
tions in the Tampico-Misantla Basin.
3. Methods
For observation of pyrite samples in this work, we followed the method used by for previous reports of microorganisms in sedimentary pyrite from the Agua Nueva Formation [10,11]. Samples were fractured into fragments of approximately 1 cc. Later, the innermost part of sample was taken in order to avoid any kind of contamination. Samples were gold coated during three minutes. After coating, they were placed into the Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM-JEOL-JSM-6300, resolution of 300,000×, 35 kV) for microscopic observation at the Centro de Investigaciones en Ciencias de la Tierra y Materiales, of the Universidad Autónoma del Estado de Hidalgo.
4. Description of the Stomatocysts from the Agua Nueva Formation
A total of 6 forms of chrysophycean stomatocyst were described from the sedimentary pyrite embedded in the limestone of the Agua Nueva Formation cropping out in Xiltla, Central Mexico. They were described and compared on the basis of their morphological characteristics following the criteria established by in the Atlas of Chysophycen Cysts [15], in marsh salt sediments [20] and in the website Stom@tocysts and Co (http://www.stomatocysts.unibe.ch/) [14].
4.1. Spherical Specimens with Smooth Surface
Stomatocyst specimen I: (Figure 4(A))
Taxonomic position: Unknown SEM Description: The specimen 1 is a globose structure with a spherical morphology. It has a width of approximately 8.1 mm, which is equivalent to the equatorial length, and a total length of 8.3 mm. It exhibits a smooth surface lacking of any kind of ornamentation or rugose texture. The distal part of the anterior region of the specimen exhibits a pore, which is observed in lateral view and reaches 1.2 mm in length. No collar is present around the pore. No more details were observed in this specimen.
Stomatocyst specimen II: (Figure 4(B))
Taxonomic position: Unknown SEM Description: The specimen 2 is a globose structure with a spherical morphology being slightly wider than longer. It has a length of approximately 7.5 mm, and a total length of approximately 7.0 mm, which is equivalent to the equatorial length. The specimen exposes a smooth surface lacking of ornamentation or rugose texture. The distal part of the anterior region of the specimen exhibits a pore, which is notorious only in lateral view. Its shape is not recognizable but in lateral view it has a length
Figure 4. Fossil stomatocysts observed in the sedimentary pyrite from the Agua Nueva Formation at Xilitla, Central Mexico. (A) and (B) Spherical specimens showing smooth surface. (C) Spherical specimen with rugose surface showing proyections; (D) Fragmented oval specimen with smooth surface; (E) and (F) Oval specimens exposing a rugose surface.
of approximately 1.0 mm. No collar is present around the pore. No more details were observed in this specimen.
4.2. Spherical Specimens with Rugose Surface
Stomatocyst specimen III: (Figure 4(C))
Taxonomic position: Unknown SEM Description: The stomatocyst is quite spherical. It has a diameter varying from 6.4 mm in its equatorial portion and 6.8 mm in its antero-posterior length. Its surface is not smooth and exhibits a rugose surface. Anteriorly, in lateral view, the specimen exposes a small projection that could represent a collar around the pore, but more details were not observed. In the anterior part of the cyst, at approximately 50˚ from the collar, the cyst from Xilitla exposes two protuberances, one of them broken and the other one showing a round distal part. The rounded projection has a length of 1.7 mm and a width of 2.5 mm, whereas the broken structure has a length of 1.4 mm and a width at the base of 1.7 mm. More details were not detected.
4.3. Oval Specimens with Smooth Surface
Stomatocyst specimen IV: (Figure 4(D))
Taxonomic position: Unknown SEM Description: The stomatocyst is oval in shape. Its width (equatorial length) reaches 6.3 mm whereas its total length is of 9.8 mm. Its visible surface is smooth lacking of ornamentation such as projecting structures. The pore is visible in lateral view. Because of the preservation state of the specimen, neither the size nor other morphological features of the pore were estimated.
4.4. Oval Specimens with Rugose Surface
Stomatocyst specimen V: (Figure 4(E))
Taxonomic position: Unknown SEM Description: The stomatocyst is about 1.63 times longer than wider showing an ovoidal morphology. Its width, which seems to be equivalent to the equatorial length, reaches 4.2 mm, whereas its length reaches 7.2 mm. Its surface is not smooth because it exposes a kind of rugose texture along the visible portion of the body, which extends from the anterior to the posterior region. This texture is quite similar than the observed in the specimen III. The cyst lacks of any kind of known ornamentation or projecting structures. The origin of the rugose texture in the surface of the specimen remains unknown. This specimen exhibits a well-exposed circular pore. It is regular and has a diameter of 0.71 mm. It lacks of a collar, annulus and pseudoannulus.
Stomatocyst specimen VI: (Figure 4(F))
Taxonomic position: Unknown SEM Description: The stomatocyst is oval in shape with a width (equatorial length) of 5.6 mm and an anteroposterior length of approximately 9 mm. It surface is not smooth, and exposes a kind of rugose aspect covering its whole surface, and lacks of any kind of ornamentation such as reticulum or projecting elements. The anterior pole of specimen bears a pore, which is appreciated in lateral view only. It exposes a length of 0.9 mm. More details were not observable.
5. Discussion
5.1. The Sedimentary Environment and the Morphological Affinity of the Stomatocysts from Xilitla
Sedimentary pyrite is a mineral commonly formed under anoxic conditions in both continental and marine environments [36]. Furthermore, these conditions also promote the establishment of well-laminated sediments with high content of organic matter. At the study area, the Agua Nueva Formation exposes such features typically assigned to environments with a deficient concentration of oxygen, such as the presence of well laminated dark micritic limestone, high content of organic matter an relatively well preserved fossil biota [30,31]. As additional data, the fossil biota of the Agua Nueva Formation consists mainly in microfossils corresponding to several forms of planktonic organisms such as globotruncanid and heterohelicid foraminifera, as well as calcispheres and radiolarian mainly. On the other hand, the fossil macrobiota consists of several forms of ammonites, inoceramids as well as fishes that indicate that this lithologic unit was accumulated in open marine waters [29] within a paleogeographic late Cretaceous element known as Cuenca-Tampico-Misantla [33].
Within the sedimentary pyrite embedded in the limestone of the Agua Nueva Formation, the stomatocysts here described were found. According to the morphology, size and presence or absence of ornamentation, the spherical and no ornamented specimens showed some possible affinity with the morphotype 189. The oval and rugose specimens also have some affinity according to their morphology to morphotypes 118 and/or 121; whereas the spherical and rugose specimen with anterior projections remains unidentified. The stomatocysts are common found in lakes [20], streams [37] and brackish [20] sediments and they are not common in the open marine realm [19]. Spherical and smooth morphologies corresponding to morphotype 189 above enlisted have been largely reported as components of sediments in marsh (brackish) [20] and fresh-water [15] environments. Similar situation has been assigned to the oval morphotypes 118 or 121 that correspond to fresh-water specimens. Reports of stomatocysts in the marine realm consist mainly of Archaeomonads cysts, which have been reported for the Caribbean [21], for the subantarctic Southwest Pacific; Norwegian Sea, and the Atlantic realm [22,24,25]. This group corresponds to planktonic oceanic forms that live in the photic zone and produces well-ornamented cysts, or smooth and spherical forms (e.g. Archaeomonas spherica) with a diameter longer than the 11 mm, which does not match with any specimens described for the sedimentary pyrite of Xilitla. On the other hand, studies on the distribution of siliceous microfossils in superficial bottom sediments of the Gulf of Mexico [26] also reported the presence of stomatocyst in sediments from the Gulf of Mexico basin, however, they are rare in those deposits and it seem to have a fresh-water origin being transported from continental to marine realms throughout ancient rivers [26]. According to this data, the presence of stomatocyst in the basinal sedimentary pyrite of the Agua Nueva Formation is notable. The Agua Nueva Formation, as mentioned above, was deposited under open marine conditions within the Cuenca TampicoMisantla basin during the late Cenomanian throughout early Turonian [33]. At that time, the input of terrigenous material into the outer shelf and adjacent basinal areas was supplied by deltaic systems established at approximately 1000 km northward, at the Appalachian and Oachita trends (Figure 3) [33]. This paleogeographic arrangement could explain the presence of non-marine stomatocyst in this lithologic unit. However more detailed studies are required to confirm this hypothesis.
5.2. Pyrite Sedimentary and the Stomatocysts from Xilitla
Sedimentary pyrite is a mineral, which fossilization potential is relative high and a great diversity of fossils, mainly macrofossils have been collected from sedimentary pyrite in several localities in the world, such as plants and fruits from the Eocene London Clay in England [38] or different groups of metazoans (e.g. nautiloids, conodonts, bivalves and gastropods) from the Late Devonian of Poland [39] among many other famous localities. However, the presence of microscopic elements is less common or even rare. Most of them consist of different morphologies of bacterial remains such as coccoid [4,5,9,10,28], or bacilli [4], or even structures associated to bacterial activity such as piritized discs from Black Meza, Arizona, United States of America [40]. Other kinds of microscopic biostructures are less common or rare, such as diatoms [12], pollen-like structures [11] and cysts [13]. A previous work [28] reported a round and globose unidentified structure from sedimentary pyrite from the Agua Nueva Formation at Xilitla, Central Mexico. This report could represent the first known record of stomatocyst in late Cretaceous marine waters.
6. Conclusion
Six forms of stomatocysts were described from Upper Cretaceous sedimentary pyrite of the Agua Nueva Formation in Central Mexico, which were deposited under open marine conditions within the Tampico-Misantla basin (Central-Easthern Mexico) during the late Cenomanian throughout early Turonian. Comparison between the forms of Xilitla and other previously reported show that the Xilitla specimens show more affinities with brackish and fresh-water specimens than with marine species. It suggests that some ancient rivers could supply continental material with stomatocysts into the marine realm. This report could represent the first known record of stomatocyst in Late Cretaceous marine waters.
Acknowledgements
Special thanks go for Mr. Gustavo Sánchez Juárez (UAEH) for the edition work of the figures showed in this paper. A.B. thanks to Programa al Mejoramiento del Profesorado (PROMEP: Project No. 72636363), and the Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnología (CONACYT: Project No. 83849) for providing finantial support for fieldwork and collecting data at the locality of Xilitla.